General

INTERVIEW | Major risks in composite structures

INTERVIEW | Major risks in composite structures

Anyone commissioning a building from skilled professionals expects it to comply with regulations and meet fire safety requirements. But the reality is different. The assessment method underpinning the regulations has gaps. Furthermore, compliance with the regulations does not guarantee that a building is ‘fire-resilient’.

Fire classification under scrutiny

This is the conclusion reached by Ruud van Herpen, senior fire safety consultant and technical director at Nieman Raadgevende ingenieurs. “The requirements seem clear,” he observes. “Larger buildings are divided into compartments to slow the spread of fire. We provide escape routes and limit the spread of smoke. The requirements for load-bearing and separating structures are clear. What is unclear, however, is how composite structures can meet them. This creates fire risks, particularly in multi-storey housing.”

Individual components

Individual components are adequately tested using small-scale test methods. The materials used in structures are tested to check that they meet the required fire classification, while fire-resisting partitions are tested to establish whether their fire resistance is sufficient. Van Herpen: “However, these measures are rendered ineffective if fire can spread along the façade, bypassing the fire compartments.”

Fire classification under scrutiny

A stark example is the fire at Grenfell Tower in London in 2017. The fire broke out on the fourth floor of the 24-storey building and was initially considered ‘harmless’. But the flames reached the combustible façade panels, the flammable insulation material and combustible elements in the façade structure. The tower block was completely destroyed by fire. “That woke us up,” says Van Herpen. “Since then, the fire classification of external walls has been under scrutiny. Assessors and engineers across Europe are still investigating how to test whether composite structures meet the required fire classification. The fact that individual components in a structure meet fire classification B does not mean that the structure as a whole does.”

Better guidance

Van Herpen also teaches practitioners at TU Eindhoven, where he shows building engineers how to tackle the problem at source. He helps them understand the purpose of the requirements, offers solutions for façades and teaches them how to make detailing reliable, so that a fire does not ‘spread’. He also provides guidance through his own consultancy.

“Dividing buildings into compartments using fire-resisting partitions is a sensible, effective measure,” he says. “It gives people time to escape and allows assistance to be provided. But the failure rate of these partitions can reach 50%. We seem to consider this acceptable, even in sustainable buildings. I see things differently. A building is considered sustainable when it achieves a high sustainability rating. Fire safety, however, is not part of such a rating, making a total-loss fire scenario a real possibility. You cannot honestly claim that a building with a total-loss fire scenario is sustainable.”

New risks

There is still much to do in the field of fire safety. Airtight construction is creating new fire scenarios, while an ageing population brings new fire risks. How effective are escape routes in residential care homes if most residents have limited mobility or dementia and cannot use them? “We are more aware of the risks that already exist, but new risks are constantly emerging too. Regulations need to respond to these developments more quickly.”  

Vraag over dit verhaal? Stel je vraag

Blijf dit volgen

Bij een nieuw verhaal krijg je een e-mail. Geen account nodig.

Wat je volgt
  • OnderwerpGeneral
Deel dit artikel

Advertentie

Volgen op Beton & Staalbouw

Volg

Bij een project of bedrijf krijg je een e-mail zodra er een nieuw verhaal over verschijnt, bij een thema of onderwerp één keer per week een overzicht. Geen account en geen wachtwoord: in elke mail staat een link naar wat je volgt.