General

The Pen | Prof. Dr P.J. Boelhouwer, Professor of Housing Systems at TU Delft

The Pen | Prof. Dr P.J. Boelhouwer, Professor of Housing Systems at TU Delft

A donkey doesn’t stumble over the same stone twice…

After years of VINEX housing development, the Dutch housing sector is entering an entirely new era, in which building within cities will become the norm. The State of Housing report shows that 80% of the land currently available for housing development is located in cities. This represents a major shift in direction, since the figure has been around 30% in recent years. The types of homes to be built on these sites will also differ greatly from those built during the VINEX era, when large numbers of ground-level family homes were delivered. Apartments in the somewhat higher price brackets will predominate on the new inner-city sites.

As many new development sites are located on former industrial estates, the construction of more affordable homes is under considerable pressure. The question is whether we are repeating the same mistake as in the 1960s, when, in line with the modernist thinking of urban planners, large areas of the Netherlands were filled with high-rise deck-access flats. Even then, many behavioural scientists warned that these homes did not meet the prevailing preferences of many young families. When they had the opportunity to move to the growth towns, where many ground-level homes with gardens were on offer, these households left the high-rise in droves. The sharp drop in demand eventually brought the construction of deck-access flats to an almost complete halt. The largest block of flats from that era, De Knoepert in Venlo, with 499 homes, was never fully occupied and was spectacularly demolished in 1999.

As in the 1960s, urban planners and, for the most part, progressive city councils are adamant that the answer lies in building apartments, this time not cheap ones but expensive ones. Anyone who dares to voice a cautious reservation is quickly branded an environmental or open-space criminal. Yet, just as in the 1960s, this elite’s choice is completely at odds with the current housing preferences of people looking for a home. The latest WoON survey by BZK shows that no less than 57% of people intending to move prefer a ground-level home, usually one to buy. 30% choose a rental apartment, but these are mainly first-time movers relying on social housing. Only 16% opt for a flat to buy. And those are precisely the homes that will be coming onto the market in large numbers over the next few years! The survey also shows that the vast majority of people intending to move would prefer to live in a green residential environment. Working from home during the coronavirus pandemic has only strengthened this preference. Faced with these preferences, some urban enthusiasts say that residents will simply have to get used to this, and will soon want nothing else. The fact that many families are currently leaving cities in large numbers is, of course, ignored.

Why, then, have our city councils made this rather reckless choice? Well, one of the main reasons is the desire to preserve open space and nature. Apparently, in making this choice, they have not listened to the many nature organisations, such as the World Wide Fund for Nature and Staatsbosbeheer, which are actually calling for nature to be created outside cities through housing development. For many, this is surely an appealing prospect. Increase the share of the Netherlands occupied by housing from 7 to 8%, and substantially expand the number of nature reserves at the expense of highly polluting agriculture. A sound business case that can count on broad support from left to right.

Nor have any lessons been learned from the building crisis in the United Kingdom. A parliamentary inquiry led by Sir Letwin concluded that the stagnation in construction output could not be explained, as had initially been assumed, by a shortage of sites or construction capacity, but by housing programmes that did not reflect market demand. The main recommendation was to build fewer expensive flats for sale, which in the UK are also often bought by foreign speculators. The UK has also begun building a number of new growth villages and towns.

In light of all this, we may ask whether, within a generation, we will once again make the monumental mistake of paying little or no heed to prevailing housing preferences. Surely a donkey doesn’t stumble over the same stone twice….

Vraag over dit verhaal? Stel je vraag

Blijf dit volgen

Bij een nieuw verhaal krijg je een e-mail. Geen account nodig.

Wat je volgt
  • OnderwerpGeneral
Deel dit artikel

Advertentie

Volgen op Beton & Staalbouw

Volg

Bij een project of bedrijf krijg je een e-mail zodra er een nieuw verhaal over verschijnt, bij een thema of onderwerp één keer per week een overzicht. Geen account en geen wachtwoord: in elke mail staat een link naar wat je volgt.