Concrete

‘Concrete maintenance should be managed, not endured’

Tekst Tjerk van DuinenBeeld CPS, Foppe Schut

De consoles van een woongebouw worden voorzien van een wapeningscontact. (Beeld: CPS)
De consoles van een woongebouw worden voorzien van een wapeningscontact. (Beeld: CPS)

Thinking in terms of extending service life

The concrete sector is good at carrying out repairs, but less adept at taking a strategic approach. That is the view of Anthony van den Hondel, director of Cathodic Protection Supplies. He says maintenance of concrete structures too often lags behind the damage. Cathodic protection (CP) can play a key role, provided it is properly understood and used strategically.

Concrete maintenance is often taken for granted. And that approach is often where things go wrong. “You can’t just ‘maintain’ concrete,” says Van den Hondel. “Yet I still see a lot of routine: following the fixed inspection rounds in the MJOP, or intervening only when damage becomes visible. Both approaches are risky, because corrosion of reinforcing steel starts invisibly. By the time you can see it on the surface, it’s usually too late. At the same time, intervention sometimes happens too early, simply because the plan says so. That costs money when it isn’t technically necessary.”

Cathodic protection is being installed on the parapet of an office building. (Image: Foppe Schut)

Condition-based maintenance

Timing is everything in concrete maintenance. “That’s why I advocate condition-based maintenance,” says Van den Hondel. “In practical terms, that means measuring and investigating first, then making a decision. Concrete is ideally suited to this. You can determine the condition of a structure fairly accurately and compare scenarios on that basis: what happens if I do nothing now? Or if I apply different measures? This is about more than just the technical aspects. It also involves disruption to users, feasibility and costs over the service life. CP can play a role here. It isn’t a solution for everything and certainly isn’t a standard measure, but it is one of the few techniques that actually stops the corrosion process. That makes it an interesting option from an asset management perspective. So the question shouldn’t be how much CP costs, but what it does to the total maintenance burden over the coming decades.”

CP power supply for a viaduct: measuring is knowing. (Image: CPS)

Misconceptions

Van den Hondel identifies a number of persistent misconceptions in concrete maintenance practice. “The first is treating asset management and maintenance as separate. Asset management without maintenance is little more than empty words on paper. Maintenance without asset management has no direction. Thinking in terms of extending service life means weighing measures against risk reduction, remaining service life, disruption, feasibility and Total Cost of Ownership. Anyone serious about extending service life must assess measures in terms of risk reduction and their effect over time. CP is often a good fit, precisely because it stops the most important damage process.”

What is needed

Another misconception is the belief that there is one standard solution. “You can’t develop a sound strategy without a diagnosis. Sometimes a measure is too extensive, sometimes it doesn’t go far enough. Applying CP to an entire bridge isn’t automatically worthwhile either. It’s about what is needed. Failing to compare scenarios is really a missed opportunity. That brings me to the third misconception: seeing monitoring as a sign of weakness or as ‘hassle’. CP is an active system, so yes, you have to take measurements. But that is precisely its strength. It is more or less the only technique that lets you demonstrate objectively what is happening and how it develops over time. That data turns the structure into a source of information and helps make maintenance predictable.”

Applying an overlay to a CP system on the floor of a car park. (Image: CPS)

Taking control

This leads straight to misconception number four. Van den Hondel says: “Many asset managers would rather wait until the next maintenance period, but fixed MJOP cycles are often too crude. That can lead to a structure being closed for four weeks, only for the closure to last fourteen. That isn’t bad luck, but the result of not having enough information in advance. Maintenance then becomes something that happens to you, when in fact you can take control of it.” But an even bigger misconception is number five: treating uncertainty as a reason to do nothing, while corrosion simply continues. “Uncertainty should instead prompt further investigation or temporary control measures. Doing nothing is rarely neutral; it almost always makes the eventual intervention more expensive.”

Rust stains point to severe corrosion in a bridge’s prestressed beam. (Image: CPS)

“A different way of thinking should prevail in the concrete sector,” concludes Van den Hondel. “Less repairing what breaks, more taking control of what you do and when you do it. Smart preservation starts with diagnosis and the right timing. CP can then be a very valuable tool, provided it is used as part of a strategy, not out of routine.” 

Vraag over dit verhaal? Stel je vraag

Blijf dit volgen

Bij een nieuw verhaal krijg je een e-mail. Geen account nodig.

Wat je volgt
  • OnderwerpConcrete
Deel dit artikel

Advertentie

Volgen op Beton & Staalbouw

Volg

Bij een project of bedrijf krijg je een e-mail zodra er een nieuw verhaal over verschijnt, bij een thema of onderwerp één keer per week een overzicht. Geen account en geen wachtwoord: in elke mail staat een link naar wat je volgt.