Steel

Steel mediates between old and new in the renovation of Binnenhof Building J

Tekst Tjerk van DuinenBeeld RVB, Frank Hanswijk, Nico de Bont en Tjerk van Duinen

Gebouw J: een rijk gedetailleerd werk van Rijksbouwmeester Cornelis Peters. (Beeld: RVB/Frank Hanswijk)
Gebouw J: een rijk gedetailleerd werk van Rijksbouwmeester Cornelis Peters. (Beeld: RVB/Frank Hanswijk)

Building J, the former Ministry of Justice, is currently completely covered in scaffolding on the Plein in The Hague. This design by Government Architect Cornelis Peters was used largely by parliamentary groups in the House of Representatives until a few years ago. Following the renovation, the listed building will serve, among other things, as an office and meeting venue and will house the Central Information Point for MPs and staff. In this sixth instalment of our series on the renovation of the Binnenhof, we look at the structural interventions needed in particular beneath the roof zone, where new floor sections are being installed and an additional storey will support the heavy new climate control systems. This involves weaving new load-bearing structures into a listed building.

The Rijksvastgoedbedrijf entrusted the renovation of Building J to specialist restoration contractors. Van Hoogevest Architecten designed the project, bringing the building’s original richness fully back to the fore. The work is being carried out by restoration contractor Nico de Bont, which is part of the TBI construction consortium for the renovation of the House of Representatives complex, together with J.P. van Eesteren (construction) and Croonwolter&dros (building services). Arcadis is responsible for the structural engineering advice. This article focuses in particular on the roof zone, where new third- and fourth-floor slabs are being built. Structurally, the work involves adding complete floor sections within an existing building envelope, with limited floor-to-floor heights and a listed façade that cannot simply be loaded.

Frank Blokdijk, site coordinator at Nico de Bont, in front of the fully wrapped building. (Image: Tjerk van Duinen)

Independent steel structure

This calls for very careful decision-making. “Perhaps the most important decision was what we would allow to carry loads and what we would not,” says Frank Blokdijk, site coordinator at Nico de Bont. “We are effectively building the third floor over the existing floor. This new floor does not transfer loads to the existing floor structure, but to an independent steel structure. Loads will be transferred via newly installed steel elements that function independently, both vertically and horizontally, of the existing timber and masonry structures. This prevents historic elements from inadvertently becoming load-bearing.”

Point clouds

Before the engineering phase, the building was surveyed in detail using point clouds based on existing scans and additional measurements by the steelwork supplier. “With existing buildings, dimensional accuracy cannot be taken for granted,” says Blokdijk. “You have to contend with sagging trusses, out-of-plumb elements and details that have been altered over time.” To enable reliable calculations, most of the floor was first stripped back, exposing the timber trusses and columns. Arcadis then carried out a detailed scan, and the resulting point cloud formed the basis for the digital building model. ‎‎

Building J is part of the House of Representatives complex. (Image: RVB)
Rendering of the steel hammerheads. The tapered beam sections at the façades leave room for building services. (Image: Nico de Bont)

Hammerheads

The main loads from the new floors are transferred via steel hammerheads fixed to the listed façades with chemical anchors. The hammerheads carry the vertical loads from the floor beams and transfer them to the load-bearing masonry. “These façades are substantial,” says Blokdijk. “We are talking about masonry walls around 600 millimetres thick.” The hammerheads, prefabricated by Vic Obdam, are mechanically fixed with chemical anchors. The load-bearing capacity of the masonry and the distribution of forces have both been carefully calculated. The steel-to-masonry interfaces are detailed to avoid a direct, rigid connection, preventing stress concentrations and unwanted acoustic bridges. All steel in contact with the external façades is hot-dip galvanised for additional protection against moisture.

Compromised structural frame

When the structures were exposed, it became clear that alterations had been made in various places over the years, including around the lifts and building services. Sections of trusses had been locally altered or even removed, disrupting the original load paths. Rather than relying on temporary fixes, the team opted for additional steel structures, including collars, tie rods and portal frames, to re-establish continuous load paths. “Steel acts as a corrective here,” explains Blokdijk. “Not to replace the old, but to make the structure work logically again. Digital models based on the point clouds make it possible to size and position these interventions precisely.”

The prefabricated hammerheads are mechanically fixed with chemical anchors in the thick masonry façades. (Image: Tjerk van Duinen)

Structurally independent

A key design principle is acoustic decoupling between the old and the new. This has direct implications for the structural detailing. Existing timber columns, which originally continued down to the floors below, are structurally ‘encased’ in new steel and cut off at the bottom. “Those columns must no longer form part of the new load path,” Blokdijk continues. “By completely enclosing them, we can saw them off below without compromising load-bearing capacity. This creates a floor structure that is structurally independent while closely matching the existing structure geometrically.”

Existing timber columns are structurally ‘encased’ in new steel and cut off at the bottom. (Image: Tjerk van Duinen)

Building services

As well as the structure’s own weight and imposed loads, building services play a decisive role in the design. A high density of services is being installed in the roof zone, including air handling units, ducts and pipes, some of which will sit on the new floors. “These services are no afterthought,” stresses Blokdijk. “They determine where steel can be positioned, where openings are needed and where reinforcement is required. The steel structure has been adapted accordingly, with tapered sections, recessed channels and carefully positioned openings. In some areas, pipes are routed alongside rather than through the beams, with the sections locally modified to limit deflection and stress peaks. For acoustic decoupling, the services are mounted on spring assemblies rather than elastomers, as otherwise their weight would be difficult to control adequately. The springs are selected to suit the loads and performance requirements and are fitted with mechanical restraints.”

Fire safety as a design constraint

Fire safety also influences the structural choices. Timber trusses and joists are treated with fire-retardant coatings that have been tested in advance on combinations of timber and steel. Joints and gaps wider than one centimetre are filled, as the coating can only accommodate limited expansion. “These are not aesthetic details, but critical design constraints,” says Blokdijk.

Temporary structures

In addition to the permanent structure, temporary steel is needed for scaffolding and propping during construction. Some temporary structures run through several storeys to ensure safe working without loading existing elements. Where possible, reclaimed steel is used. “It is structurally suitable and aligns with our sustainability ambitions,” says Blokdijk. A pragmatic approach is also taken to corrosion protection: steel that will not be visible is coated using available leftover paint.

The roof structure is being strengthened with steel. (Image: Tjerk van Duinen)

Ultimately, the complex steel structures in Building J will be largely invisible to users. “Steel here is 100% functional and indispensable,” concludes Blokdijk. “It makes new uses possible without making the listed building carry additional loads or fail under today’s requirements. If we do our job well, what you see is the building designed by Peters. The new structures simply do their job in the background.”

Vraag over dit verhaal? Stel je vraag

Wie aan de renovatie van het Binnenhof werkte

  1. opdrachtgeverRijksvastgoedbedrijfGenoemd in Renovating the former Ministry of the Colonies: a building from the Iron Age
  2. integraal adviseur voor het Tweede Kamercomplexde Architekten Cie.Genoemd in 1913 architectural ingenuity uncovered during Binnenhof renovation
  3. TBI-bouwcombinatieJ.P. van Eesteren, Croonwolter&dros en Nico de BontGenoemd in Site offices for 500 people on Plein for Binnenhof renovation
  4. bouwcombinatieHeijmans BurgyGenoemd in Foundation repair and strengthening at the Binnenhof using grout and gel
  5. hoofdconstructeurABTGenoemd in World market leader at work on Binnenhof renovation
  6. constructieve adviezenArcadisIn dit verhaal
  7. funderingsbedrijfKeller FunderingstechniekenGenoemd in World market leader at work on Binnenhof renovation
  8. staalbouwerVic ObdamGenoemd in Steel contractor rises to the challenges of renovating the Binnenhof
  9. circulair staalVan Ee StaalspecialistenGenoemd in Circular observation tower gives residents something back during Binnenhof renovation
  10. ontwerpBERNS architectuurGenoemd in 1913 architectural ingenuity uncovered during Binnenhof renovation
  11. adviseurBeersNielsen LichtontwerpersGenoemd in 1913 architectural ingenuity uncovered during Binnenhof renovation
  12. adviseurBremen BouwadviseursGenoemd in 1913 architectural ingenuity uncovered during Binnenhof renovation
  13. adviseurDGMRGenoemd in 1913 architectural ingenuity uncovered during Binnenhof renovation
  14. adviseurSmits van BurgstGenoemd in 1913 architectural ingenuity uncovered during Binnenhof renovation
  15. adviseurKarres en BrandsGenoemd in 1913 architectural ingenuity uncovered during Binnenhof renovation
  16. adviseurOngehinderdGenoemd in 1913 architectural ingenuity uncovered during Binnenhof renovation
  17. adviseurLevel AcousticsGenoemd in 1913 architectural ingenuity uncovered during Binnenhof renovation
  18. adviseurHospitality GroepGenoemd in 1913 architectural ingenuity uncovered during Binnenhof renovation
  19. uitvoeringJ.P. van Eesteren | TBIGenoemd in 1913 architectural ingenuity uncovered during Binnenhof renovation
  20. installatiesCroonwolter&drosGenoemd in 1913 architectural ingenuity uncovered during Binnenhof renovation
  21. aannemerHeijmansGenoemd in Site offices for 500 people on Plein for Binnenhof renovation
  22. ontwerpWDJArchitectenGenoemd in Renovating the former Ministry of the Colonies: a building from the Iron Age
  23. akoestiekLevel Acoustics & VibrationsGenoemd in Renovating the former Ministry of the Colonies: a building from the Iron Age
  24. uitvoeringNico de BontGenoemd in Renovating the former Ministry of the Colonies: a building from the Iron Age
  25. jetgrouttechniekKellerGenoemd in Foundation repair and strengthening at the Binnenhof using grout and gel
  26. bouwcombinatieBouwcombinatie Heijmans BurgyGenoemd in Foundation repair and strengthening at the Binnenhof using grout and gel
  27. funderingsbedrijfVSFGenoemd in Foundation repair and strengthening at the Binnenhof using grout and gel
  28. architectVan Hoogevest ArchitectenIn dit verhaal
  29. betonleverancierDyckerhoff BasalGenoemd in Renovating the Binnenhof: an anatomy lesson
  30. koolstofadditiefCarStorCon TechnologiesGenoemd in Renovating the Binnenhof: an anatomy lesson
  31. gerecycled betongranulaatUrban MineGenoemd in Renovating the Binnenhof: an anatomy lesson
  32. architectBiermanHenketGenoemd in Binnenhof renovation adds fifth historical layer to Eerste Kamer roof structure

Blijf dit volgen

Bij een nieuw verhaal krijg je een e-mail. Geen account nodig.

Wat je volgt
  • ProjectRenovatie Binnenhof
  • ThemaBouwen in de bestaande stad
  • OnderwerpSteel
  • BedrijfArcadis
  • BedrijfVan Hoogevest Architecten
Deel dit artikel

Advertentie

Volgen op Beton & Staalbouw

Volg

Bij een project of bedrijf krijg je een e-mail zodra er een nieuw verhaal over verschijnt, bij een thema of onderwerp één keer per week een overzicht. Geen account en geen wachtwoord: in elke mail staat een link naar wat je volgt.