Projects

Renovating the Binnenhof: an anatomy lesson

In the Eerste Kamer buildings, existing basements are being deepened and new basements constructed.
In the Eerste Kamer buildings, existing basements are being deepened and new basements constructed.

Trial and error beneath the Senate

Under the Senate buildings, a largely hidden operation is under way that is exemplary of the Binnenhof renovation. The existing basement is being excavated to a greater depth and new basements are being built. This involves fitting new floors between old foundations, temporary steel structures and recently strengthened foundations. It is precision work, involving changing phases and continual reinterpretation. A monumental workplace where technical design and construction constantly demand the utmost care from each other.

Excavation of the basements also exposed recently installed foundation reinforcements (grout walls). (Image: Rijksvastgoedbedrijf)

Anyone walking through the renovated rooms of the Senate in future will see no trace of it. The steel props and jacks will have disappeared, temporary excavations filled in, improvised routes dismantled and foundation repairs or reinforcements concealed from view. The same is true of many other interventions that form part of the vast renovation of the Binnenhof complex: in the end, they are hidden from sight. This eighth instalment in our series on the renovation looks at a delicate but highly interesting operation. Following the foundation reinforcement beneath the Senate buildings (see the report in the January issue this year), work recently began on creating new basement floors in this part of the complex. A concrete trial using CO2-negative aggregate was also successfully completed.

An apparent tangle of props, jacks, old foundations, temporary steel structures and recently strengthened foundations. (Image: Rijksvastgoedbedrijf)

Between layers of history

On paper, the task seems straightforward: create new basement floors beneath the existing sections of the building, providing space for services, technical equipment and future use. In practice, the complexity begins with the word ‘existing’. The Senate complex is not an easily understood structure, but a layering of construction phases, extensions, restoration campaigns and local interventions from different centuries. Even when correctly shown on drawings, the old walls are not always where a rational plan would place them. The foundations follow their own historical logic, and beneath the current floor lies the result of recent strengthening measures using a specialist grouting technique. Anyone looking to add a new structural layer here is therefore working not in, but between layers of history.

This makes it an interesting project for ABT, which is responsible for the structural and geotechnical design of the Senate buildings. Structural engineer Earnest Alderliesten puts it this way: “Here, you are dealing with existing foundations, old basements and quay walls from different centuries. We have to fit new structures among them, in a controlled way and without damaging the historic elements. In new-build projects, the load paths are more or less fixed in advance. Here, they have to be established afresh each time, sometimes confirmed and sometimes revised. Scans, point clouds and destructive investigations reveal a great deal, but it is only when floors are opened up and soil removed that the building reveals its true anatomy.” And that anatomy is more challenging, richer and less predictable than any model can fully capture in advance.

All hands on deck for the first concrete pour. (Image: Rijksvastgoedbedrijf)

Every element has to be right

This is no simple matter of excavating and pouring floors. Steel frames, spreader beams, horizontal struts and auxiliary structures on screw injection piles, with hydraulic jacks to support existing columns, combine to form a temporary skeleton that keeps the building intact while work takes place beneath it. Heijmans site manager Wilco van Bethlehem speaks about this with the calm of someone who knows that agitation adds little to the task. “The temporary situation is just as challenging as the end result,” he says. “You have to make room to build the floor, while ensuring that everything remains safe.” It is precisely in this interim state that the quality of design and execution becomes apparent. Every element has to be right: sequence, dimensions, reaction forces, monitoring and timing. 

A telling moment during construction came when excavation to deepen part of a basement revealed that a jet grout wall installed earlier was not performing as expected in one area. The team opted for additional excavation in small sections, a new analysis and local remedial measures. 

The 110-metre-long pipeline, from the concrete pump at the Stadhouderspoort to the Senate basement, was a particularly critical element.

A new layer

In this underground archive, deviations are not exceptions but a constant. This makes close cooperation between consultant and contractor decisive. At this stage, ABT and Heijmans are working closely together, not for organisational efficiency but out of technical necessity. Whenever site conditions differ from expectations, the structural engineer has to go back to the drawing board, while the contractor needs to know how much flexibility remains in the construction sequence. “Then we have to take a step back and work out how to solve it,” says Van Bethlehem. Monitoring is an integral part of the process. Movements and deformations are tracked with Total Stations to check whether the structure is behaving as predicted by the calculations and in line with the chosen construction phase. The first concrete pour for the new floors took place in early May. According to Alderliesten, this adds a new layer to the history of the complex. “Here, the floor is not a finish to the basement, but the new link between heritage and future use.” 

Koploper concrete will soon feature in the Senate and Council of State buildings. (Image: Rijksvastgoedbedrijf)

A convincing result

Alongside the complex basement operation, a trial of CO2-neutral concrete was carried out. Heijmans poured several formwork boxes in the Senate basement using a mix based on blast furnace cement and Clim@Add, a carbon additive from CarStorCon Technologies that can significantly reduce concrete’s CO2 footprint. The very long pipeline, connected to an electric trailer-mounted pump and measuring around 110 metres, was a particularly critical element. Van Bethlehem says the product has convincingly made the transition from laboratory promise to construction practice. “The mix used for the final trial pour was stable and met all the requirements. We will now also use Clim@Add for plinths and floors in this sub-project. It was easy to place and vibrate, and came out of the formwork with a smooth finish.” This is essential, as alternative mixes often fall short when it comes to workability. 

Koploper concrete

Vincent van der Plas, concrete technologist at concrete supplier Dyckerhoff Basal, also sees the trial as significant. “This was not a case of simply adjusting one parameter. The entire mix design was reconsidered, using blast furnace cement, secondary raw materials and a modified carbon additive within the applicable quality frameworks.” According to Alderliesten, the trial shows that a substantial reduction in CO2 emissions is already possible within current standards. “As well as Clim@Add, 30% of the gravel was replaced with high-quality recycled concrete aggregate from Urban Mine. ‘The Road to 2030’, the roadmap for the Betonakkoord’s CO2 reduction targets, sets ceiling and frontrunner values for the maximum emissions of concrete mixes. The mix used here comes in at around 79 kilograms of CO2 equivalent per cubic metre. This is well below the frontrunner values prescribed by the Betonakkoord for 2027 and beyond. At the same time, the concrete fully complies with current legislation and regulations.”

Koploper concrete beneath a column supported by jacks. (Image: Rijksvastgoedbedrijf)

The Binnenhof thus provides a valuable real-world trial of more sustainable concrete under demanding conditions. Concrete containing Clim@Add will also be used for the floors in the Council of State. This concrete was selected thanks to close cooperation between RVB, Heijmans and ABT. Alderliesten concludes: “RVB has also stuck its neck out to set an example with koploper concrete. It is important for the government to take the lead in this.” For RVB, this step fits seamlessly with its ambition to renew listed state buildings in a future-proof and responsible way, with the lowest possible environmental impact. What has been tested beneath the Senate could therefore prove to be a wider point of reference for the use of concrete in complex renovation projects.    

The trial formwork box with Clim@Add was a success.

Question about this story? Ask your question

Who worked on the renovation of the Binnenhof

  1. clientRijksvastgoedbedrijfMentioned in Renovating the former Ministry of the Colonies: a building from the Iron Age
  2. Multidisciplinary consultant for the Tweede Kamercomplexde Architekten Cie.Mentioned in 1913 architectural ingenuity uncovered during Binnenhof renovation
  3. TBI construction consortiumJ.P. van Eesteren, Croonwolter&dros and Nico de BontMentioned in Site offices for 500 people on Plein for Binnenhof renovation
  4. construction consortiumHeijmans BurgyMentioned in Foundation repair and strengthening at the Binnenhof using grout and gel
  5. Lead structural engineerABTMentioned in World market leader at work on Binnenhof renovation
  6. structural engineering adviceArcadisMentioned in Steel mediates between old and new in the renovation of Binnenhof Building J
  7. Foundation contractorKeller FunderingstechniekenMentioned in World market leader at work on Binnenhof renovation
  8. steelwork contractorVic ObdamMentioned in Steel contractor rises to the challenges of renovating the Binnenhof
  9. circular steelVan Ee StaalspecialistenMentioned in Circular observation tower gives residents something back during Binnenhof renovation
  10. designBERNS architectuurMentioned in 1913 architectural ingenuity uncovered during Binnenhof renovation
  11. adviserBeersNielsen LichtontwerpersMentioned in 1913 architectural ingenuity uncovered during Binnenhof renovation
  12. adviserBremen BouwadviseursMentioned in 1913 architectural ingenuity uncovered during Binnenhof renovation
  13. adviserDGMRMentioned in 1913 architectural ingenuity uncovered during Binnenhof renovation
  14. adviserSmits van BurgstMentioned in 1913 architectural ingenuity uncovered during Binnenhof renovation
  15. adviserKarres en BrandsMentioned in 1913 architectural ingenuity uncovered during Binnenhof renovation
  16. adviserOngehinderdMentioned in 1913 architectural ingenuity uncovered during Binnenhof renovation
  17. adviserLevel AcousticsMentioned in 1913 architectural ingenuity uncovered during Binnenhof renovation
  18. adviserHospitality GroepMentioned in 1913 architectural ingenuity uncovered during Binnenhof renovation
  19. constructionJ.P. van Eesteren | TBIMentioned in 1913 architectural ingenuity uncovered during Binnenhof renovation
  20. building servicesCroonwolter&drosMentioned in 1913 architectural ingenuity uncovered during Binnenhof renovation
  21. contractorHeijmansMentioned in Site offices for 500 people on Plein for Binnenhof renovation
  22. designWDJArchitectenMentioned in Renovating the former Ministry of the Colonies: a building from the Iron Age
  23. acousticsLevel Acoustics & VibrationsMentioned in Renovating the former Ministry of the Colonies: a building from the Iron Age
  24. constructionNico de BontMentioned in Renovating the former Ministry of the Colonies: a building from the Iron Age
  25. Jet groutingKellerMentioned in Foundation repair and strengthening at the Binnenhof using grout and gel
  26. construction consortiumHeijmans Burgy construction consortiumMentioned in Foundation repair and strengthening at the Binnenhof using grout and gel
  27. Foundation contractorVSFMentioned in Foundation repair and strengthening at the Binnenhof using grout and gel
  28. architectVan Hoogevest ArchitectenMentioned in Steel mediates between old and new in the renovation of Binnenhof Building J
  29. concrete supplierDyckerhoff BasalIn this story
  30. carbon additiveCarStorCon TechnologiesIn this story
  31. recycled concrete aggregateUrban MineIn this story
  32. architectBiermanHenketMentioned in Binnenhof renovation adds fifth historical layer to Eerste Kamer roof structure

Keep following this

Get an email when a new story is published. No account needed.

What you follow
  • ProjectBinnenhof renovation
  • ThemeLess CO2 In concrete and steel
  • SubjectProjects
  • CompanyDyckerhoff Basal
  • CompanyCarStorCon Technologies
  • CompanyUrban Mine
Share this article

Advertisement

Follow on Beton & Staalbouw

Follow

Follow a project or company and you’ll receive an email whenever a new story appears. Follow a theme or topic and you’ll receive a weekly roundup. No account or password needed: every email includes a link to what you follow.