Steel

The importance of testing in steel frame construction

Tekst Roel van GilsBeeld CFP Engineering

Testen zijn een essentieel onderdeel voor systeemgedrag, verbindingen en bijzondere detailleringen, niet voor elk standaardproduct.
Testen zijn een essentieel onderdeel voor systeemgedrag, verbindingen en bijzondere detailleringen, niet voor elk standaardproduct.

From assumptions to demonstrable structural safety

Steel frame construction is a collective term for applications of thin-walled, cold-formed steel products. It has a wide range of applications, but is not consistently covered by standards. Designs often rely on assumptions, leaving essential aspects such as stability, connections and local effects structurally underexamined. Cor van Zandwijk of CFP Engineering emphasises the importance of testing: “Physical tests reveal what models cannot always fully predict.”

In recent years, a clear trend has emerged: the demand for clear standards and design rules is growing, observes Van Zandwijk. “An important step was taken in 2019 with the development of a standard for mezzanine floors. Its aim was to make the market more mature by establishing uniform principles for design and tendering. This also helps create a level playing field, where suppliers can substantiate their products in a comparable and, above all, verifiable way.”

CFP’s test rigs have a span of up to 7 metres and a width of 3 metres, with a capacity of 2 x 25 tonnes.

Testing and validation

Despite the tremendous advances in software and calculation methods over the past 10 to 15 years, we still often fall back on assumptions, Van Zandwijk points out. “In practice, many structures are designed and used on the basis of experience: ‘we’ve been building it this way for years, so it must be fine’. But in reality, that tells us very little. Industrial mezzanine floors are often designed for an imposed load of 500 kg/m2. However, that does not mean the design can be demonstrated to be safe under all conditions. Safety depends on the correct modelling, detailing, execution and validation of critical mechanisms. The behaviour of cold-formed steel products is often complex and difficult to model fully using FEM calculations. Predicting failure mechanisms accurately is challenging, and that is precisely where the risk lies. In such cases, testing is often the most direct way to validate models and establish the actual behaviour of a structure.”

Local failure

This applies not only to floors, but to all projects in which steel frame construction forms a structural part of the overall structure. “Local failure or instability can occur suddenly, especially in thin-walled sections and connections. The argument that something has never collapsed before does not hold water. Extreme loads, such as heavy snowfall or exceptional wind forces, do not occur every year, but when they do, the consequences can be severe. History shows that structural failures often only come to light when something goes seriously wrong. Think of well-known collapses where it later emerged that essential components were missing or inadequately designed. When a structure fails, it rarely happens gradually: often, it goes badly wrong all at once.”

Variety of details 

It is striking, then, that fire safety is tested extensively, while structural testing remains relatively limited, says Van Zandwijk. “This is remarkable, given the wide variety of details and connections in steel frame construction that are difficult to model. Other sectors, such as racking, carry out extensive testing. Companies there invest millions every year in load tests to validate their products. There is good reason for this. The same understanding needs to take hold in steel frame construction. Not everything can or should be based on assumptions. Testing is essential for system behaviour, connections and unusual details, though not for every standard product. Only then can steel frame construction develop into a mature and reliable building method.”

CFP Engineering deliberately uses testing to validate calculation models and details. “We have test rigs with a span of up to 7 metres and a width of 3 metres, with a capacity of 2 x 25 tonnes. This flexible setup allows us to carry out a wide range of tests in steel frame construction, from floor deflection and loads on racking to investigations of sandwich panels and façade sheets. We also conduct small-scale tests, using setups of up to 10 kN, for example, to test screw pull-out.”   

Vraag over dit verhaal? Stel je vraag

Blijf dit volgen

Bij een nieuw verhaal krijg je een e-mail. Geen account nodig.

Wat je volgt
  • ThemaBouwen als productieproces
  • OnderwerpSteel
Deel dit artikel

Advertentie

Volgen op Beton & Staalbouw

Volg

Bij een project of bedrijf krijg je een e-mail zodra er een nieuw verhaal over verschijnt, bij een thema of onderwerp één keer per week een overzicht. Geen account en geen wachtwoord: in elke mail staat een link naar wat je volgt.