Sustainability & circularity

Circular steel construction: how feasible is it in practice?

Circular steel construction: how feasible is it in practice?

Van Den Brink Metaalbewerking takes a sustainable approach to awareness, collaboration and innovation. The company has already delivered several circular construction projects. Klaas Roos, Managing Director, also saw an opportunity to take a circular approach to a project of his own: an extension to the company’s workshop. ‘I wanted to experience for myself what it’s like to work with reused steel. To find out what it means in practice.’

Although he managed to get them for the price of ordinary scrap, Klaas found steel with a story. ‘They were riveted beams from the old Palace of Justice. They date from 1885 and were above the courtroom. If they could talk, they’d have some wonderful stories to tell. We converted them into columns for our workshop.’

Circularity

There is a lot of talk about circular construction. But what does it actually mean? ‘It’s not as simple as it seems. Steel is inherently a material that lends itself extremely well to reuse. You can supply it as scrap, and a complete logistics system is in place to melt it down. But all that scrap is first loaded onto a ship bound for China. There, it is melted down, often in a highly polluting process, after which the new steel beams are loaded onto a ship and sent back to us. If you calculate how much energy is lost in the process... It’s unbelievable. It really makes you wonder what you’re doing.’

‘You’d think, then, that reusing steel directly here would be much cheaper and more energy-efficient. But even then, you run into issues. You need to know what kind of steel you’re using. That means having it inspected and certified. It costs a lot, and certification doesn’t come as part of the deal. Then there’s the question of what the steel has been treated with. Often, it’s something that has to be removed. If it’s Chromium-6, it has to be removed at a specialist facility. The stuff is extremely toxic, of course. All in all, it quickly becomes cheaper to use new steel. So you have to make a principled decision to opt for circular steel.’

It is hardly surprising, then, that there are still few takers. ‘The only people choosing it at the moment are eccentrics like us, who simply enjoy working on this kind of innovation. For most companies, circular construction isn’t financially viable or desirable. And even for us, there are limits. I did look into whether we could use circular materials for the roofing, too, but the price tag was more than I’m prepared to pay at the moment.’

Feasibility

So when it comes to circular construction, the biggest challenge doesn’t seem to lie in whether it is desirable, or in the logistics or technology? ‘No, it really is a question of feasibility. The steel taken from existing buildings, for example, dates from 1980 or 1990. The standards have changed since then. If you demolish an entire building somewhere and rebuild it elsewhere, is it a new building or a second-hand one? And what does that mean for the standards? If you strengthen and reinforce the structure to meet the new standards, it not only costs a lot of money, it also undermines the circular concept.’

The supply of used steel is also so limited at present that it is almost impossible to meet demand. ‘A municipality asked for circular steel for a bridge. Where on earth am I supposed to find it? Even if I can find it, I’ll end up with beams with all sorts of tabs and holes in them. What do you do with those? And that’s not even getting into the challenge of making a structure fit. Using circular steel often means designing a structure around the steel available, rather than the other way round. Very few clients are willing to do that.’

Scaling up

‘If you want to get this off the ground properly, you have to think and act on a much larger scale. For example, you could bring several municipalities together and make plans for a depot where circular steel can be stored. Municipalities know better than anyone where demolition work is coming up. They would need to work together to demolish buildings carefully and collect the materials. That would create the volume needed. Specialists would have to be brought in to test and treat the material at the depot. And standards and certification would also need to be addressed at a higher level. It can all be done, but it requires a large-scale, collaborative approach.’

First steps

Genuinely circular steel construction raises a lot of questions, for example about the possibilities for recertifying used steel. Have these questions come up late? ‘No, I understand why. They come up when you start working on it. That’s when you run into these kinds of issues. In practice, we can already do a great deal when it comes to reusing steel. The agreements and processes around it still need to be put in place by the whole industry and government. Until then, it will continue to take a lot of adaptability and money.’

Could we one day have to conclude that circular steel construction will remain too expensive compared with “new” steel made from scrap? ‘Well. If the whole market started using it on a large scale, less scrap would eventually be supplied to blast furnaces. The price of steel would then rise because more virgin raw materials would be needed. The balance would have to shift considerably.’

Investing

Even so, Klaas believes it is well worth the effort. ‘It takes an unbelievable amount of energy to ship all our scrap, have it melted down in Chinese blast furnaces and transport it back again. It is also an extremely polluting process. The Netherlands has some of the cleanest blast furnaces in the world, but we know how people react when we try to melt down large quantities of scrap here at home.’

Meanwhile, Klaas wants to be a good steward. ‘I can’t solve this problem on my own, of course. But I do want to take steps and give it a try. And I also think our new workshop is a really cool project, with a great story. An honest story. So I’ll stay actively involved in this subject, and I’ll try to get my clients, suppliers, partners and the government interested. Because if nobody does anything, nothing will happen.’

Get involved?

The entire industry faces a huge challenge when it comes to circular steel construction. But who doesn’t love a challenge? Would you like to discuss the opportunities, or share your experience with the subject? Get in touch with Klaas Roos at Van Den Brink Metaalbewerking or Niels Oudenaarden at Liemar Software. We’d love to hear your views.

Vraag over dit verhaal? Stel je vraag

Bedrijven in dit verhaal

Blijf dit volgen

Bij een nieuw verhaal krijg je een e-mail. Geen account nodig.

Wat je volgt
  • ThemaMinder CO2 in beton en staal
  • OnderwerpSustainability & circularity
  • BedrijfLiemar Software BV
Deel dit artikel

Advertentie

Volgen op Beton & Staalbouw

Volg

Bij een project of bedrijf krijg je een e-mail zodra er een nieuw verhaal over verschijnt, bij een thema of onderwerp één keer per week een overzicht. Geen account en geen wachtwoord: in elke mail staat een link naar wat je volgt.