Sustainability & circularity

‘The KCI programme poses a dilemma for many asset managers’

Tekst Roel van GilsBeeld Royal HaskoningDHV

Door het uitgestelde onderhoud staan we nu voor een opeenstapeling van vervangings- en renovatieopgaven.
Door het uitgestelde onderhoud staan we nu voor een opeenstapeling van vervangings- en renovatieopgaven.

Many of the civil engineering structures in the Netherlands were built in the second half of the last century. Traffic has increased exponentially since then, while maintenance of these structures has repeatedly been deferred. Although this was done on a risk-based and responsible basis, the fact remains that deferred maintenance has now left us facing a backlog of replacement and renovation work. In this, the advisers and engineers at Royal HaskoningDHV see a major tension with the sustainability objectives of the government-wide ‘Climate-Neutral and Circular Infrastructure’ programme, known as KCI.

With a huge amount of replacement and renovation work on the horizon, asset managers will also have to change tack on sustainability.

The Netherlands has enshrined its climate targets in law. These targets have been translated into the KCI programme for national infrastructure, which aims to make that infrastructure fully climate-neutral and circular by 2030. The provinces have also embraced the KCI programme, with the Interprovincial Consultation (IPO) responsible for its implementation. The fact remains that maintenance of structures in the Netherlands has been delayed for all kinds of reasons. “With the exception of a few landmark structures, all maintenance work has been put on the back burner by Rijkswaterstaat, the provinces and municipalities. We are now seeing the consequences,” says Bert Hesselink, Leading Professional Steel Bridges at Royal HaskoningDHV, who works, among other things, on recalculating the capacity of existing structures and determining what measures are needed. “Some structures only need a thorough ‘clean-up’, while others require more far-reaching measures. In the most extreme cases, complete replacement is needed. And now the KCI programme’s sustainability requirements have been added to the mix.”

Changing tack

Until a few years ago, sustainability as we now understand it in the context of the KCI programme was rarely an explicit consideration when carrying out maintenance, says Peter Gosselink, Sustainability Adviser at Royal HaskoningDHV. “With a huge amount of replacement and renovation work on the horizon, asset managers also need to change tack on sustainability. Many asset managers tend to stick with what they know. This gives them confidence that the structure will function reliably and safely in line with RAMS targets. However, the KCI programme also calls for innovation, the introduction of new techniques and materials, and different ways of organising processes. This creates considerable tension with what asset managers are familiar with. Opportunities to improve sustainability often conflict with the standards and guidelines currently in force. As a Sustainability Adviser, I find that fascinating, but getting all stakeholders on board is a challenge. Compromises will have to be made to resolve this tension. We cannot necessarily achieve everything we set out to do.”

Until a few years ago, sustainability as we now understand it in the context of the KCI programme was rarely an explicit consideration when carrying out maintenance.

Starting a dialogue

Gosselink says that many existing standards and guidelines need to be revised if we are to get closer to the shared sustainability goals agreed under KCI. “Rijkswaterstaat and ProRail aim to be fully circular and climate-neutral by 2030. The provinces have also embraced that ambition. It is a great goal to work towards, but the challenges are enormous and time is running short. Some of the projects currently on the programme will not get under way until 2030 or later. At the same time, the steps we can take to change the culture are small. What I mean is that the KCI sustainability goals and RAMS requirements will have to converge at some point before then. Earlier this year, Royal HaskoningDHV issued a public call for us to start a dialogue on updating standards and guidelines in line with the KCI goals. It is good to see so much energy being devoted upfront to working out how to pursue the stated goals through policy. But when projects get under way, we too often see those goals quickly lose out to other priorities. We call that ambition erosion.”

Look beyond the individual structure

According to Hesselink, large-scale replacement and renovation work tends to focus mainly on the structure itself. “From a sustainability perspective, it is much more interesting to look at the bigger picture, rather than focusing solely on sustainable material use and emissions-free construction.” Gosselink adds: “Renovating a bridge generally disrupts traffic across the network and requires temporary diversions. The environmental impact of those measures is often many times greater than that of the replacement or renovation work itself. This is particularly true of structures on motorways, where large numbers of vehicles have to make long detours for an extended period. Is renovation really the smartest choice? Or should you replace the bridge early and raise it at the same time, so that the movable section is no longer needed? You also start looking differently at the choice of materials. Steel, composites and precast concrete, for example, do not need time to cure during installation, unlike cast-in-situ concrete. A longer construction period means longer traffic disruption and an even greater environmental impact. These are all factors that we at Royal HaskoningDHV can calculate and bring to people’s attention.”

Guidance

How does circularity relate to sustainability in replacement and renovation work? “The two themes have a lot in common, but at times their interests conflict,” says Hesselink. “A design may sometimes require more materials to provide a solution that is fit for the future. At first glance, that does not align with the aim of using fewer raw materials and reducing environmental impact, but future-proofing is an important principle of sustainability.” Gosselink also recommends taking existing guidance into account when planning replacement or renovation work, including guidance published under the KCI programme mentioned above. “The KCI programme is important to the civil engineering sector because it brings together a wealth of practical knowledge and expertise. Make the most of it.”

Materials passport

From the perspective of circularity and sustainability, the two men advocate the widespread introduction of materials passports into business operations. “These should contain information about the function, composition, origin and usage history of materials,” says Gosselink. “That could include information about the coatings used or whether a material contains hexavalent chromium, for example. The passport must become an integral part of every project, so that in decades to come it will be possible to consider reusing a component elsewhere. Platform CB’23 has developed an excellent template for this, but it needs to be embedded in business operations for data management. Our clients are not there yet. Components regularly become available that we would like to reuse, but we do not know their origin or composition, which makes it difficult to find a suitable new purpose for them.” That is not to say that nothing is being reused. Hesselink says: “Two years ago, we upgraded a cycling and pedestrian bridge in the Achterhoek, reinforcing the existing steel bridge with steel from a nearby demolished factory building. That is circularity at its best. Steel is, of course, a fantastic material from a circularity perspective and can be reused indefinitely, provided its history is taken into account. That is why it is so important to introduce materials passports properly.” 

Vraag over dit verhaal? Stel je vraag

Blijf dit volgen

Bij een nieuw verhaal krijg je een e-mail. Geen account nodig.

Wat je volgt
  • ThemaBruggen en kunstwerken langer mee
  • OnderwerpSustainability & circularity
Deel dit artikel

Advertentie

Volgen op Beton & Staalbouw

Volg

Bij een project of bedrijf krijg je een e-mail zodra er een nieuw verhaal over verschijnt, bij een thema of onderwerp één keer per week een overzicht. Geen account en geen wachtwoord: in elke mail staat een link naar wat je volgt.