Beware of geopolymers: sustainable and circular concrete pavements
Tekst Roel van GilsBeeld Wim Kramer

The infrastructure sector is constantly looking for new ways to reduce the carbon footprint of projects. After all, projects are awarded on the basis of a favourable Environmental Cost Indicator (MKI) score and low CO2 emissions. In road construction, attention quickly turns to ways of further reducing CO2 emissions from materials such as asphalt and concrete, and cement in particular. This has led to pavement structures made from elephant grass concrete, fibre-reinforced concrete or geopolymer concrete. Wim Kramer, a concrete specialist with 35 years’ experience in the cement and concrete industry, is particularly sceptical about the contribution geopolymer concrete can make to an environmentally friendly and sustainable future.
For decades, the Netherlands has been a global leader in the use of low-CO2 cement types. “The current CO2 savings in the cement we use are achieved mainly through a high proportion of blast-furnace cement and the use of fly ash in Portland-fly ash cement as alternative raw materials, as well as transport by water,” says Kramer. “But the concrete and cement industries are not standing still either. Extensive research is being carried out and pilot projects are under way involving low-CO2 cement and, in turn, lower-CO2 concrete. There is also a great deal of experimentation with material reuse. Today, a high-performance crusher can even break concrete down completely to cement-grain level, producing a fraction that can be reused in the cement industry.”

Fibre-reinforced concrete
Clients are imposing increasingly stringent sustainability and circularity requirements on infrastructure projects. “Road builders are working hard with the concrete industry to develop smart mixes that deliver a favourable MKI score and low CO2 emissions from concrete pavements, helping them win contracts,” says Kramer. “Fibre-reinforced concrete is a good example. It allows you to build thinner. It is already used fairly regularly in practice for white topping, for example to extend the service life of worn asphalt cycle paths. A thin concrete overlay incorporating a structural fibre in the mix, and also making use of the residual strength of the asphalt, can significantly extend the pavement’s service life. It also uses less material and requires less to be delivered, which means further CO2 savings compared with an entirely new standard pavement structure.”

According to Kramer, a cycle path is therefore an ideal testing ground for new initiatives. “There is not much that can go wrong. And if a new initiative ultimately does not work out, all that is needed is to replace or overlay the surface course, with no major consequences or significant disruption for road users. This is how valuable, positive experience has been gained with fibre-reinforced concrete.”

Geopolymer concrete
The search for ways to reduce concrete’s CO2 footprint has also focused on low-CO2 binders. “Geopolymer concrete is increasingly seen in the Netherlands as the solution for substantially reducing concrete’s CO2 footprint,” Kramer says. However, he has his doubts. “A cycle path in Overijssel, built using red-coloured geopolymer concrete, developed significant surface damage quite soon as a result of de-icing salts and frost. This is not usually an immediate structural problem, but the structure will not achieve its intended service life, and riding comfort deteriorates rapidly. Quite apart from the aesthetic aspect….” This is why geopolymer concrete paving blocks and slabs are given a cement-based surface layer during production. “This makes the surface more resistant to frost and de-icing salts,” Kramer says. “The damage to the cycle path in Overijssel was so extensive that several slabs have already been replaced. And last year, a cycle path in Utrecht made from coloured geopolymer concrete was also completely replaced with conventional concrete shortly after it was laid, due to deterioration of the structure. That does not deliver any CO2 savings.”

A broader perspective
There is another aspect of geopolymer concrete that often receives too little attention. Kramer explains: “In geopolymer concrete, cement is replaced by an alkali-activated binder. In north-western Europe, this is generally made using blast-furnace slag or pulverised fuel ash, both of which are rapidly becoming less available. Coal-fired power stations are being closed at an accelerated rate, and Tata Steel is under pressure from society and has already announced plans to switch to a different steelmaking process that will produce far less suitable slag. And this is despite the fact that the cement industry is already using almost all the available slag and fly ash in its cements. Geopolymers can certainly help reduce CO2 emissions, provided they do not use raw materials already used by the cement and concrete industries, which have helped make the Netherlands a leader in the use of low-CO2 cement and ready-mixed concrete. From a broader perspective, you are simply shifting raw materials from one use to another, cancelling out any CO2 benefit. Geopolymers can therefore only help limit CO2 emissions if they use raw materials that are not yet used in the cement and concrete industries. These could include artificially produced slag, as well as other secondary material streams, although the volumes available are usually limited.”
Acid resistance
We should not imagine that geopolymer concrete will replace all concrete, Kramer concludes. “And certainly not in road infrastructure. By contrast, trials with precast internal walls for housing made from geopolymer concrete have produced good results. In that application, there is no risk of external deterioration. It has also proved suitable for manufacturing sewer pipes, thanks to specific properties such as acid resistance, but the overall scale of these applications is very limited. It is clear that, given the limited availability of raw materials, geopolymer concrete production in its current form cannot be scaled up to the point where it replaces a significant proportion of conventional concrete based on conventional cement. For most applications in (road) infrastructure, geopolymer concrete also has inferior properties to conventional concrete. Moreover, geopolymer concrete cannot yet be considered circular. For example, it cannot be used with conventional recycled concrete aggregate as a secondary aggregate. It makes sense to use waste streams that are not used in cement and concrete, such as copper slag, for geopolymer concrete when this application delivers the greatest environmental benefit.”

Low-CO2 cement
Kramer concludes that geopolymer concrete makes only a very limited contribution to further improving the sustainability of concrete pavements, particularly when used in in-situ (road) infrastructure. So what is the alternative? “The answer will be to use low-CO2 cement. Cement plants in Norway, for example, are investing heavily in equipment to capture all the CO2 generated during production. Low-CO2 cement will be produced this way within a few years. As you know, cement accounts for the largest share of CO2 emissions from concrete. If we can reduce that substantially, we will make real progress, especially in combination with a high-performance crusher that also allows the cement fraction to be reused.”
Vraag over dit verhaal? Stel je vraag
Blijf dit volgen
Bij een nieuw verhaal krijg je een e-mail. Geen account nodig.
- ThemaMinder CO2 in beton en staal
- OnderwerpConcrete


















