General

#5: Reducing CO2 in concrete: how collaboration is making the concrete supply chain more sustainable

#5: Reducing CO₂ in concrete: how collaboration is making the concrete supply chain more sustainable
De podcast laadt pas als je op afspelen klikt.

Host: Roel Van Gils

How can you reduce concrete’s CO₂ emissions without compromising strength, durability and workability? Roel van Gils discusses this with Sigrid Mulders of Dura Vermeer, Pierre Hendrikx of ABT, Vincent van der Plas of Dyckerhoff Basal and Gerard Roelofsen of Sika Nederland. They talk about using less Portland clinker, CEM III/B and CEM VI, admixtures, delayed hardening, pilot projects and, above all, why collaboration across the concrete supply chain is crucial to making concrete more sustainable.

Gerard Roelofsen: Sika Nederland
Sigrid Mulders: Dura Vermeer
Pierre Hendrikx: ABT
Vincent van der Plas: Dyckerhoff Basal

Een zakelijke vraag aan Sika Nederland B.V.? Neem contact op

Volledig transcript

Alle hoofdstukken (25)
  1. Introduction: less cement and lower CO2 emissions
  2. Introductions
  3. Why the conversation starts with cement
  4. The impact of design choices
  5. Workability and conditions
  6. The concrete supplier at the table
  7. Technically, more is possible
  8. Standards and delayed hardening
  9. How concrete standards fit together
  10. Concrete as a specific product
  11. Admixtures, fillers and the water-cement ratio
  12. High-strength mixes and accurate dosing
  13. Sustainability across different sectors
  14. Pilots and knowledge sharing
  15. Contract forms and early collaboration
  16. Practical trials and self-healing concrete
  17. The contractor’s sustainability ambition
  18. Collaboration and concrete as a process
  19. Supply chain knowledge and understanding standards
  20. New generations of admixtures
  21. Dosing and application expertise
  22. The batching operator’s experience
  23. Advice for the industry
  24. Responsibility in the supply chain
  25. Collaboration as the common thread

Introduction: less cement and lower CO2 emissions

Roel van Gils Welcome to a new episode of Beton & Staalbouw, the podcast. Concrete is indispensable in the built environment, yet it is also responsible for a significant share of CO2 emissions. The biggest culprit? Cement? Or, more specifically, Portland clinker in cement? The question is simple, then, but the solution is anything but, I think. How can you use less cement without compromising strength, durability, workability and reliability? That is what we are discussing today with four players from across the supply chain. By working together, we can make real progress. So I have four guests around the table: Sigrid Mulders, Pierre Hendrikx, Gerard Roelofsen and Vincent van der Plas. Welcome, everyone.

Sigrid Mulders Thank you.

Introductions

Roel van Gils Shall we go round and introduce ourselves briefly? Shall I start with the lady at the table?

Sigrid Mulders I’m Sigrid Mulders. I actually qualified as a timber structural engineer, but, perhaps surprisingly, ended up in the concrete sector via building defects. At my employer, Dura Vermeer, I get to help make the concrete sector more sustainable. I do that partly through projects, implementing the quick wins, and partly through pilot projects to achieve tomorrow’s quick wins.

Roel van Gils There you go.

Pierre Hendrikx I’m Pierre Hendrikx. I’ve been working at ABT for just over a year. Before that, I spent eight years at BAM. I went in with the idea, based on my higher professional education, that the best way to learn about construction is to get close to the work on site. And I was lucky enough to find that the concrete technologist was almost ready to retire and wanted to hand over his responsibilities. That was just before the sustainability storm really started to gather. So I was able to learn the basics first, and then suddenly sustainability came along. It’s a fascinating field, at the interface between structural engineering and concrete technology. Being able to bridge the two is also why I know the others around the table so well.

Vincent van der Plas I work for Dyckerhoff Basal in the south-west region. I’ve been doing this for a year and a half now. Before that, I was head of quality at Martens beton. Before that, I was a concrete technologist at Struyk Verwo. And before that, I poured and made a lot of concrete floors with two friends. I actually started out at the age of sixteen, trowel in hand. So I really come from the world of practice.

Gerard Roelofsen Yes, I’m Gerard Roelofsen. I work at Sika, known for its admixtures, and provide companies with technical advice. Sustainability is one of the issues that really matters to me too. I especially enjoy seeing how the rest of the world approaches it, particularly across the global Sika group. Everyone looks at it in their own way. It’s really interesting to learn about best practice in other countries and then see how we can apply it here in the Netherlands.

Lees het volledige transcriptTranscript inklappennog 23 hoofdstukken

Why the conversation starts with cement

Roel van Gils Right, great. Thank you. Once again, welcome, everyone. The sustainability storm is here. Why does the conversation always start with cement?

Pierre Hendrikx Since the introduction of LCAs, or life-cycle assessments, we’ve been able to see the environmental impact of the raw materials in a cubic metre of concrete. It quickly became clear that cement accounts for somewhere between 15 and 80 per cent, depending somewhat on the type of cement. And if you break that down to see what cement contains and where the greatest impact lies, you arrive at the binder.

Roel van Gils So what are the solutions? Perhaps that’s a very broad question to start with, but where do you begin?

Pierre Hendrikx One of the factors that will undoubtedly come up today is the water-cement ratio. I think that’s the key term when we talk about the relationship between water and cement. Other quality aspects will come into it as well. A structural engineer’s design specifies a concrete compressive strength and an exposure class. That’s essentially a minimum-requirements approach. It tells the engineer what the standard says is safe and what will ensure that the concrete lasts 50 years.

Roel van Gils And that standard has been around for a long time, I imagine.

Pierre Hendrikx Yes. The VB 74, if I remember correctly, is one of the first publications in the Netherlands on concrete mix design. If you don’t know what something does to your concrete mix, it’s hard to keep sustainability in mind, so to speak. That’s still sometimes a bit of a blind spot. So my call is: take the time to understand what goes into a concrete mix.

Roel van Gils And who are you making that call to?

Pierre Hendrikx First and foremost, structural engineers. Understand that what you specify is treated as a minimum requirement. Put the strength class and exposure class on the delivery ticket, because those can be checked on site. But when it comes to requesting a mix, you could have a C20/25 XD3 on the ticket with 50 per cent Portland clinker in the winter, for example, and it might have a compressive strength of 80 N per square millimetre at 28 days. No one will question that, because the ticket says C20/25 XD3. So take some time to understand how your design and construction choices affect the concrete mix.

The impact of design choices

Roel van Gils That opens up a whole new world. What do the others think?

Sigrid Mulders I agree. I always say that structural engineers hold the key. They have the opportunity to share information, and people act on it. I think structural engineers should be critical about the exposure classes and strength classes they specify. A good example is what you did at KJ-Plein with Basal, I think: being very deliberate about exactly where each strength class is needed. If you’ve dutifully copied onto the top floor what was once needed in the basement, although thankfully that happens less and less, the structural engineer has the power to say: we don’t need this strength class here any more. Or these walls need a different strength class from the floors. That could reduce the impact of the floor. So be critical about the strength class and the exposure class, because they ultimately lead to certain requirements for the concrete plant. You can also include this kind of sustainability information on drawings, to indicate, for example, that a strip foundation can easily be made with CEM III/B, or that it has plenty of time to gain strength. It doesn’t need to be loaded or stripped again tomorrow.

Roel van Gils Right, okay. So those are solutions that can help.

Sigrid Mulders Making concrete more sustainable partly means reducing its clinker content. Sometimes you can use more cement and still have a more sustainable, or lower-CO2, mix.

Roel van Gils How so?

Sigrid Mulders There are more than 35 types of cement.

Roel van Gils Oh, I see. You use a different cement.

Sigrid Mulders Yes. If you can produce a CEM VI, for example, you’re laughing, but yes, we’re also looking into it for a project near Rotterdam, you can work with a different cement, a different mix. You can look at clinker, slag and limestone filler, or recycled concrete fines, as Everox does, for example. So you may have used more cement, so to speak, but less clinker. Ultimately, that gives you a lower impact than a traditional CEM I.

Roel van Gils Okay. Those are great developments, of course. So there are all kinds of different parameters, different levers you can pull to arrive at the right mix.

Sigrid Mulders But you need to get the conditions right. If all you do is change the binder, without heating or using different admixtures, you still won’t get there. It really is about the combination.

Workability and conditions

Roel van Gils That may also create a different problem. I don’t know if it’s actually a problem, but workability. You obviously have to take that into account too.

Vincent van der Plas Yes, workability is of course taken into account. As Sigrid says, it’s important to discuss what everyone wants at the start of the project. When does the structural engineer need a particular strength class? Is there more time to achieve it? Can you supply concrete with delayed hardening? Is heating an option? If so, you could use CEM III/B. If it’s winter, you’ll need some Portland cement. But if heating is possible, you could switch to full blast-furnace cement, for example. It’s important to agree at the outset what everyone wants and what the ready-mixed concrete supplier can do to help. If they’re not invited to that initial discussion, little will be done to improve sustainability, because the standard mix will simply be supplied. A ready-mixed concrete supplier can’t just say, ‘I’ll supply all the concrete with nothing but blast-furnace cement’, without discussing it first. That obviously has consequences for construction. It has to be agreed together.

The concrete supplier at the table

Roel van Gils And does it happen often that you all sit down together, so to speak? As a trio? Or not nearly often enough?

Vincent van der Plas It happens quite a lot. I have several meetings every week with a whole range of contractors, including Sigrid, of course, and other contractors too. So thankfully, we’re being invited more often.

Pierre Hendrikx I’d like to pick up on that. You are often invited to the table, but in my view, often far too late. I think the market bears that out. This is partly to do with contract structures. A contractor can only join the discussion after the contract has been awarded, or beforehand as an adviser. But most contractors don’t come to the table as advisers. You can get advice from a company or concrete supplier beforehand, but that doesn’t guarantee that the contractor with the winning bid will work with that supplier. There are contracts tied to that as well.

Roel van Gils Or perhaps at the start of the project?

Pierre Hendrikx Yes, it depends somewhat on the size of the contractor and the project, and on the level of ambition. But I’ve often seen people reach the conclusion just two or three weeks before the pour that something still needed to be done about the concrete mix.

Gerard Roelofsen That’s even more true for us as an admixture supplier. We usually get a call a day or two beforehand: ‘I’ve got problems, can you please sort them out quickly?’ So, just add a bit of magic and it’ll all be fine.

Technically, more is possible

Roel van Gils But technically, much more is possible than is happening now.

Sigrid Mulders Absolutely.

Roel van Gils So what’s holding it back?

Sigrid Mulders As I just said, we also need pilots so that people can see why certain steps are necessary or make sense. With some admixtures, it’s all a bit more obvious and better understood, but I think other admixtures still need to be made more visible.

Gerard Roelofsen Sustainability is also about looking at how long something lasts, quite apart from CO2 reduction. In England, for example, it’s very common to use waterproofing products. They’re specified as standard. In the Netherlands, you still have to fight to get people to pay attention to them. That’s just the way it is.

Roel van Gils But do they also take a different approach to sustainability standards? Or is the Netherlands leading the way in that respect?

Gerard Roelofsen From what I see internationally, I’d definitely say the Netherlands is leading the way on sustainability. In terms of CO2 per cubic metre, we’re well ahead. When you tell my colleagues at Sika about it, they look at those figures in amazement.

Pierre Hendrikx Yes, and the figures bear that out. Cement production accounts for 8 per cent of the CO2 impact worldwide, but only 3 to 4 per cent here in the Netherlands.

Roel van Gils And is that down to those developments?

Pierre Hendrikx No. The main reason is that we, and some people may not like hearing this, are fortunate to have Tata Steel and the by-product it supplies, called blast furnace slag. Not to be confused with LD slag. That’s the question I get every time now: does LD slag also go into concrete? The blast furnace slag we use in concrete is produced early in the process. LD slag is produced towards the end.

Sigrid Mulders The slags we use regularly in cement production contain hardly any contaminants. They’re perfectly safe to use in concrete products and are completely different from steel slags.

Pierre Hendrikx If I remember correctly, and you can check this or cut it if it’s wrong, it has to do with the coke and coal used in blast furnace production, and the share of those materials in the by-product is purer than in LD slag. LD slag is the rocky material left over once all the iron has been extracted. So it still contains a lot of heavy metals.

Roel van Gils Yes.

Standards and delayed hardening

Roel van Gils When it comes to rules and standards, do they still reflect what is possible today?

Vincent van der Plas For example, CUR Recommendation 122 refers to a kₜ factor for delayed hardening. That’s where the Rüsch effect comes in. You have to take it into account in your concrete mix design. For higher strength classes, you have to apply this kₜ factor, which means I end up adding more cement to my concrete mix to comply with CUR 122. I think parts of the standards are a little too conservative. You can also demonstrate compliance by testing cube compressive strength or taking core samples afterwards, to show that the concrete meets the strength specified by the structural engineer.

Roel van Gils But isn’t it risky to demonstrate that afterwards?

Sigrid Mulders Not really, because afterwards you’re checking what was actually poured.

Roel van Gils Yes.

Sigrid Mulders You’re checking the product as it was made, so you know much more about what was used. I’d see it as a means of verification. And you do that using a method that’s already laid down in the standard. If there’s any doubt about whether the product has reached the required strength, there are methods for checking that too. You can use the same method here. With a long-term strength, or whatever people want to call it, you can use a different mix with a much lower impact while still guaranteeing that it reaches the same strength, or at least the same strength.

Vincent van der Plas We have tested all those mix designs in advance and have the results. But because the characteristic strength has to be higher, that’s based on a standard deviation...

Roel van Gils Yes. And I’m curious to hear what you think.

Vincent van der Plas Yes, me too.

How concrete standards fit together

Pierre Hendrikx The difficulty lies partly in how all the standards fit together. Structural engineers approach concrete from the perspective of Eurocode 2. Concrete technologists approach it from the perspective of NEN-EN 206 and NEN 8005. Site teams approach it from the perspective of NEN-EN 13670 and NEN 8670. Since we’re listing standards, there are quite a few.

Roel van Gils Yes, exactly. Just a few.

Pierre Hendrikx When we use a cement in the Netherlands, we assume it can be used generically. So whether our structure is a large bridge pier in a sea defence, a car park floor or a residential floor, the same cement is used for every application. I think there’s something there too, and that the regulations could do with a bit of a shake-up. What really surprises me, for example, is that Eurocode 2 includes a table linking the maximum water-cement ratio to the minimum cement content. But the standard doesn’t say which cement type this applies to, because we use generic cements. Yet everyone knows that CEM III performs less well in freeze-thaw resistance than Portland cement, but much better in chloride migration resistance, for example. So I think we should take a closer look at these requirements. Suppose I have an outdoor structure that gets salted and is exposed to freeze-thaw de-icing salts. Take a car park floor, for instance. It’s often barely exposed to actual frost, for example when it’s below ground level, but it is exposed to de-icing salts brought in on tyres. If we specify a blast furnace cement for that, we can reduce our environmental impact a little further. And we can also achieve concrete performance that better matches the actual exposure it will face. We need to look at chloride migration in a more structured way, and consider the advantages of that cement and what they mean for durability. That means looking at something different.

Concrete as a specific product

Pierre Hendrikx You mentioned the triangle earlier: the structural engineer, the concrete technologist and the contractor. In my view, every structural engineer should keep their own design in mind and translate it into what it means for construction and, therefore, for the concrete mix. And if they specify a sustainable concrete mix, they should consider the impact it will have on construction. If you keep doing what you’ve always done, you’ll keep getting what you’ve always got. We won’t make progress that way.

Sigrid Mulders I just wanted to pick up on that, because I think the idea of treating concrete as a specific product rather than a generic one creates a huge opportunity to work with admixtures. You can focus much more on performance-based concrete and get the right concrete in the right place.

Gerard Roelofsen Yes. And not every admixture works equally well with every cement. As admixture suppliers, we have detailed tables showing which admixtures work better or less well with different cements. That lets you target the performance much more precisely. Do you want a longer open time? Or more strength?

Roel van Gils Air-entraining agent.

Gerard Roelofsen Air-entraining agent, yes.

Admixtures, fillers and the water-cement ratio

Roel van Gils So, are you saying that it’s difficult to reduce CO2 emissions without admixtures?

Gerard Roelofsen If you want to lower the water-cement ratio, you’ll need them. You can’t do it without them. That can also create other problems, depending on the composition of the concrete, especially now with all the new fillers and sands. Some are more exotic than others. They bring their own specific problems or challenges.

Roel van Gils But those can be solved.

Gerard Roelofsen Yes, they certainly can. But I do think there’s a lot more we can get out of this.

Roel van Gils What’s your view, Pierre?

Pierre Hendrikx I completely agree. I’m glad you’ve made the distinction between admixtures and fillers. You can reduce CO2 emissions without admixtures, but, as you say, if you have to maintain the water-cement ratio... The name says it all: water-cement ratio or water-binder ratio. Many fillers cannot be counted as binders. So you can add them, but you’ll still need to add binder to meet the strength requirements demonstrably. Optimising particle packing is one example of something we could do very little about perhaps twenty years ago. But today, with computers, the possibilities and, above all, the models we can run digitally, we could certainly make further progress.

Roel van Gils Yes.

Gerard Roelofsen And you also need quite a lot of admixture. With a very dense particle packing, the mix gets pretty stiff. Then the workability isn’t very...

Pierre Hendrikx No. Some companies have made concrete in the past with 100 kilograms of binder and made it workable. But the days of pouring floors at S2 consistency are long gone. I think F4 and F5 are more the norm than S2.

High-strength mixes and accurate dosing

Vincent van der Plas Here’s a good example: we supplied C55/67 concrete at RottaNova, made with pure CEM III/B, at F5 consistency and with a w/c ratio of 0.38. So I made extensive use of your admixtures.

Gerard Roelofsen Yes, thank you for that.

Vincent van der Plas Yes, we certainly needed them.

Gerard Roelofsen And we should say that a lot is happening in the world of admixtures at the moment. Many new types of polymer are emerging, and they’re all even more effective.

Roel van Gils Does that just make things more complex?

Gerard Roelofsen Yes. You can do more, but you need to know better what you’re doing.

Pierre Hendrikx Adding a plasticiser is all very well, but if there isn’t enough powder in the mix to ensure stability, you’ll soon see it bleed and segregate. And what kind of powder? Some powders hold everything together beautifully at first, then let go completely after fifteen minutes.

Gerard Roelofsen One issue we still come across a lot is that not everyone has their dosing properly under control, especially when using more powerful admixtures. There are still plants that are less modern, to put it mildly. They really need to modernise. Otherwise, these powerful admixtures won’t solve the problem either.

Roel van Gils Doesn’t that need to happen anyway? Do the batching plants also need to make a transition?

Gerard Roelofsen Yes. From batching plants to admixture suppliers to structural engineers, we have to work together, or it won’t work. We also need to understand each other’s challenges.

Pierre Hendrikx Definitely. And we shouldn’t assume that something new is automatically better, or that things will become easier, simpler and cheaper every time.

Sigrid Mulders I’d say it’s actually the other way round. Given how many ways there are to optimise your product, you need people. It’s a complex field, and we really need people who know what they’re doing.

Gerard Roelofsen Yes, and that is a problem. If you look at the number of people coming into the sector compared with what’s needed, we’re already short of people.

Roel van Gils And there’s still so much to build.

Gerard Roelofsen Yes, and preferably sustainably.

Sustainability across different sectors

Roel van Gils Ideally, sustainability should be a given. But anyway, you’re here, and together you can make change happen, right?

Vincent van der Plas A lot is possible.

Roel van Gils But that message needs to be communicated more widely?

Vincent van der Plas I think it varies quite a lot from one sector to another. A very large project will have more sustainability requirements than work for flooring contractors. They just want to lay a good floor and get home quickly. Their priorities are very different from those on a large residential tower. Sustainability is not given much consideration on smaller projects. I think that if we all keep sitting down together, there’s a great deal we can achieve.

Gerard Roelofsen Yes, above all, we need to keep talking. You can already see that with flooring. As well as admixtures, we supply a lot of floor coatings, for example. In a car park, the first thing my colleagues do is look for all the cracks and seal them. That is also a form of sustainability. It’s not just about the admixture; it’s also about combining concrete with a coating to reduce or prevent chloride ingress. There are plenty of technologies available, such as cover enhancers. And the coatings sector itself is also becoming more sustainable. That’s all ongoing. My colleagues often sit down with flooring companies, but they mainly talk about coatings. On very few occasions have we worked together on a floor, as we did in Hilversum. There, we took a more holistic approach to how we could prevent cracking. What could we do in the concrete to address it? There are some excellent solutions. They do add to the price of the concrete, but you make that back by not having to inject the cracks. So there’s a significant benefit there. There’s still a lot of potential.

Pilots and knowledge sharing

Sigrid Mulders You were just talking about collaboration, and Vincent said the same. Larger projects often give you more scope to try things out. So we also try to set up pilot projects. We specifically use larger projects for pilots, so that we can build trust and experience, and, above all, develop knowledge. We then try to apply what we learn more widely, making it mainstream, so that parties without the opportunity to work on such large projects, or suppliers with fewer silos, can take it into account in their development and production and make changes. But you’re absolutely right: it really has to be done together. That’s extremely important. I don’t just mean teams within companies talking to each other and saying, ‘This is what we need to do, this is an interesting pilot.’ It’s also about looking beyond the company. We’re sitting here around this table with these people, but there’s also the municipality and so many other parties we sometimes need to talk to and share notes with.

Roel van Gils So things can actually move much faster if you find out sooner.

Sigrid Mulders Yes. But my main point is that we need each other to make any of this happen in the first place. Sustainability is very much a team sport.

Contract forms and early collaboration

Pierre Hendrikx You could also ask whether the contract form most commonly used in the Netherlands is suited to a team sport. A great many projects are still tendered under the UAV, as traditional specification-based contracts. That creates a very clear divide between the pre-award and post-award stages. Once the contract has been awarded, the contractor talks to their supplier about taking the next step in sustainability. But if nothing was specified before the award, and the contractor doesn’t have a good relationship with the concrete plant, there’s no guarantee that those sustainability improvements will be made. With public-private partnerships (PPPs) or a two-phase approach, you see contract forms that bring contractors and suppliers to the table much earlier.

Roel van Gils And then we’re challenged.

Pierre Hendrikx Then they’re challenged too. At a kick-off meeting, the ambition is set out in advance: this is what we want to achieve. Everyone, you all have an equal part to play. There’s no hierarchy, no barriers between you. You’re all responsible for the end result. Go and build the best possible building.

Practical trials and self-healing concrete

Roel van Gils Was that also the motivation behind the project you just mentioned?

Vincent van der Plas Yes. At RottaNova, we sat down together early on and looked at what the emissions would be if we used conventional concrete, with some Portland clinker. We also looked at the difference if we used pure III/B, and what the implications would be for construction. We’ve made quite a lot of progress. We also poured two types of concrete there ourselves. We ran a pilot there too. We may soon be pouring CEM VI at RottaNova. I think we’ve collected quite a lot of data there.

Sigrid Mulders That’s the great thing. We were just talking about admixtures that reduce water demand or act as air-entraining agents. But self-healing additives can also eventually reduce the amount of reinforcement we need. We may not have made the concrete itself entirely more sustainable, but that still represents a huge reduction in CO2 emissions. It’s about what you do and what effect it has. You need each other for that, and you need pilots to gain experience.

Gerard Roelofsen Sika has a great deal of experience with self-healing concrete abroad. You find that it often has a harder time gaining traction in the Netherlands.

Roel van Gils Why is that?

Gerard Roelofsen That’s a good question. I don’t have an answer. Some people find it difficult to accept. They see it as an extra and say, ‘I don’t think it’s necessary.’ Then they take it out. Costs are also a consideration, and they always will be.

Roel van Gils But if you calculate the costs over the long term, it’s obviously a different story.

Gerard Roelofsen Yes. Of course, it also depends on whether you’re taking on a building where all you have to do is place the concrete, or whether you’re also responsible for maintenance. If maintenance is also your responsibility, you’ll think very differently.

Vincent van der Plas The fact that self-healing additives also extend the service life is often left out of the calculation.

Gerard Roelofsen Absolutely.

Roel van Gils Or does it also depend on the structure?

Gerard Roelofsen We have admixtures for which we can also provide guarantees. Service lives of 50 or 75 years are possible. There are conditions, of course, but it can be done. The question is, if you look beyond 50 years, most people think, ‘That’s good enough for me.’ You still see that attitude.

Roel van Gils Right?

Gerard Roelofsen Unfortunately.

The contractor’s sustainability ambition

Roel van Gils So what is most important for contractors in this whole sustainability challenge?

Sigrid Mulders We have a very strong sustainability ambition with Op naar Net Zero. It’s very important for us to play our part, act as an example and take the lead, helping others move forward. We simply can’t do it alone. We need each other to achieve our own ambitions. Ultimately, we want to be completely carbon-neutral by 2050. Our ambition is to achieve around 90 per cent through reduction measures. At some point, there will always be some residual emissions. These can be addressed using CCUS: carbon capture, utilisation and storage. But to make that happen at all, we really need each other. I think that’s a key part of our role.

Roel van Gils And initiating those pilots.

Sigrid Mulders Exactly.

Roel van Gils So how do you go about doing that?

Sigrid Mulders It depends a little on the aim of the pilot. We don’t run pilots just for show. We only run them when we think something could eventually become standard in production. If someone has a question and needs a larger project to investigate it, that’s when it gets really interesting to start working on it. Then we look at the effects. Might we need to take measurements afterwards? What would be the ideal project? Which municipality? We look closely at what’s needed. Our role varies depending on what’s needed. Sometimes we help draft notes for the municipality. That’s how our various pilots work.

Collaboration and concrete as a process

Roel van Gils Okay, great. Where do you think the next major step lies?

Gerard Roelofsen I really think it’s in collaboration. You need to calculate things across the entire supply chain. As an admixture supplier, I’d definitely like to be involved earlier: to say, ‘This is possible,’ or ‘We have a solution for that,’ or ‘We’ve got experience with it in another country. That’s how they approached it.’ In other words, sharing knowledge across borders. I think there’s still a lot of ground to make up there.

Pierre Hendrikx I’d say: stop seeing concrete as a product. That may sound cryptic, but it’s almost always how I start my presentations. Stop seeing concrete as a product and see it as a process. People think that if they just follow all the steps they’ve always followed, they can define the concrete at the end in a way that makes it sustainable. But if you don’t think from the outset about how you want to use your most sustainable concrete, you end up compromising, with your concrete mix incorporating all the decisions made earlier, simply because that’s how it’s always been done. Then you realise that if you’d thought about it more critically, you could have done something more with the concrete mix. But by then it’s already fixed in the design calculations, it’s been agreed with the municipality, and we’ve made a promise to the client. We can’t change anything now. And then the contractor comes along and wants something too.

Roel van Gils It’s always the contractors, isn’t it?

Pierre Hendrikx No, definitely not. It’s not just the contractor, the client or the consultant. Everyone has a responsibility within their part of the supply chain. One party is responsible from start to finish and gradually steps back. For another, responsibility gradually builds. Some are responsible at a particular stage. But simply explaining that process properly would already help a great deal. Broadening knowledge would help a lot too. What holds the supply chain together is really the table, with all the links resting on top of it, so to speak. That’s a very pessimistic way of looking at it. There are plenty of examples where it does work.

Supply chain knowledge and understanding standards

Roel van Gils Every project is a new one, of course. So the teams and their make-up are always changing. It’s hard to keep preaching the same message each time, so to speak.

Pierre Hendrikx That brings me back to my first point. There are three standards that all relate to concrete, but have no connection with one another. And that’s what we call the supply chain. If the structural engineer doesn’t take the time to familiarise themselves with NEN-EN 206 and NEN 8670, they’ll specify something without knowing what they’ll get. They might specify a car without knowing whether they’ll get a Fiat Punto or a Ferrari. Perhaps they had a Ferrari in mind, but end up with a Fiat. They’ll be sorely disappointed. All they’ve written down is: I want a car with four wheels, an engine and doors.

Roel van Gils Yes, exactly.

Pierre Hendrikx So it’s also about fully understanding what you specify, and setting limits. Minimum requirements, but also maximum limits. I don’t think that happens often enough yet.

New generations of admixtures

Roel van Gils Okay. Gerard, what are you working on?

Gerard Roelofsen A lot of things. In this context, a whole new generation of admixtures is on the way, particularly more powerful and effective admixtures. There are also new types of polymers and new polymer chains being developed.

Sigrid Mulders For other binders too?

Gerard Roelofsen Yes, especially for other binders. Sika actually started working on this a few years ago. The admixtures that came onto the market three or four years ago were already suitable for calcined clay cements, for example. They work perfectly well with those. But you can see that there is still more to learn. In particular, how do these kinds of fillers and cements behave? What exactly happens over time? That is what you are mainly working on. We are also seeing some new stabilisers being developed to hold things together better, or specifically to replace limestone or cement. In that case, you are effectively replacing it with a stabiliser. That is also possible. Accelerators are a hot topic at the moment, across the board. There are all kinds of experiments, both successful and unsuccessful. But, above all, we still have very little understanding of what exactly is going on. I do not think we know exactly why we are doing it or how we should approach it. For example, we have found that sometimes a more powerful water reducer can be used instead of an accelerator, with the same effect. With an accelerator, you tend to need to use a lot. The products themselves also have an EPD value. So the cure may be worse than the disease. Above all, we need to think about using the right amount, rather than just chucking something in. Digitalisation is part of this too. As Sigrid already said, we simply do not have enough concrete technologists. We also see that people often have a different approach to concrete abroad. Especially in countries where the thinking is simply: the more cement, the stronger the concrete. Those countries do exist. That can lead to some very strange discussions. I have experienced this with colleagues too. Fortunately, it worked out well, but it does happen. So digitalisation is important. It will also help to some extent. You will see that it helps determine mix designs and enables batching plants to produce better ones: what should you dose, how should you dose it, and when? What impact will that have? Should you perhaps mix for longer? Or for less time?

Dosing and application expertise

Roel van Gils Yes, because that expertise is already there. It is obviously valuable for you to guide that process too.

Vincent van der Plas Absolutely. The timing of the dosage is very important. What is its water-reducing effect? Then there is the type of admixture. You have lignosulphonates, superplasticisers, third-generation admixtures. You have to look at the intended application in every case. What is desirable where? Sometimes you can add a small amount to increase the open time instead of adding a retarder. You can experiment a little with admixtures to achieve the right workability, but perhaps also a little more open time, or a faster setting time. There are winter admixtures and summer admixtures. We also always switch to a different Sika admixture halfway through the year. And timing is important. Otherwise, you lose all the admixture if you dose it at the same time as the water. The cement absorbs the admixture.

Roel van Gils You are a major player, but does everyone know this? I mean, at the batching plants. Do you provide instructions?

Gerard Roelofsen You always provide instructions. But there are early adopters, and then there are people who say: ‘Look, I have been doing this for twenty years and it works.’ And everyone in between. Sometimes you preach the sustainability gospel to a brick wall. The next time, someone says: ‘This is exactly what I have been waiting for. Let us do something.’ There is everything in between. And just to go back to what Vincent said, you also find with admixtures, especially with the new fillers and clay products, that the admixture is absorbed, as it were, and can no longer move between the particles, so it no longer does anything. You can work with sacrificial products, for example. There are methods for this. But you need to know what you are doing. If you just say: ‘I will put it in the silo and mix it in, it will be fine…’ No, it will not. Sometimes we are left wondering: I do not understand it, I do not understand how it works. Then you have to go through everything step by step yourself: what is the mix, and what have you been pressing?

The batching operator’s experience

Pierre Hendrikx You almost have to stand next to the batching operator at the plant, watch the screens and see what is happening in the mixer via the camera.

Gerard Roelofsen Then you can see what is happening. Of course, they can add a little more or a little less water and admixture. But if you do that with an ultra-high-performance superplasticiser, it will not work.

Pierre Hendrikx If you are used to just watching the ammeter: at many batching plants you visit, when you change a mix design, the first thing the batching operator looks at is the ammeter reading. That tells them: it is a bit stiffer than usual. Then it comes out of the mixer and, sure enough, it is even stiffer. These people are so much a part of the batching plant that they are almost intertwined with it. They notice even the slightest change straight away and already know what will come out the other end. That is expertise AI will not replace. It is real insight that you need at a batching plant. And that explains what Gerard rightly said, and what I have experienced myself: sometimes a technologist has to see something before they believe it. You cannot blame them, because they are immersed in day-to-day production. They know their own products inside out. They know exactly what concrete will come out if they use their product, do this, and add that admixture. So if someone from outside suddenly turns up and says: ‘I have something new, and I can improve sustainability,’ it is a bit like someone coming to your door to sell you something. The first instinct is to think of an excuse and close the door again.

Gerard Roelofsen Yes. For example, if you tie your shoelaces, try doing it another way or from the other side. You will not get it right at first. You need experience. It is the same with admixtures. If you introduce a new admixture, the first reaction is: ‘It is not like the previous one.’ Yes, we knew that. But you need to get some experience with it now. A year later, you say: ‘Great product.’ The holy grail is to add some admixture and get exactly what we are looking for, while using even less.

Roel van Gils That would be nice, wouldn’t it?

Gerard Roelofsen That actually happened once recently. But it is rare. Everyone is looking for a unicorn, and there is no such thing. So, above all, we have to be willing to take a chance. And if it does not work once, do not give up straight away. Test for longer, keep talking to each other and keep holding a number of sessions together. What can we tweak? Then you can also see why it might or might not work.

Advice for the industry

Roel van Gils Then you have learned something for next time too. I think that is a good conclusion. But anyway, what advice would you give the industry and our listeners?

Gerard Roelofsen Do not be afraid. That above all. Do not be afraid. Just give it a try.

Sigrid Mulders And seek out opportunities to collaborate.

Gerard Roelofsen Yes, because that is very important.

Sigrid Mulders We have heard that a few times today. We are not going to compete on sustainability. If there is a company near you that is also working on becoming more sustainable, talk to them. Talk to your supplier, talk to your clients. Find out where you can get the knowledge you need, where you can find opportunities to collaborate, and work together to become more sustainable. We really are turning the tanker around, and in a few years we will have turned it a long way. Or, to put it another way, we will have made a lot of progress, particularly in terms of attitude and mindset. Once we have made some progress, we can look at what comes next. First, we really need to work together to bring about change.

Gerard Roelofsen I also think that once we have made that shift and turned the tanker around, things will move faster and faster. It will become second nature to talk to each other and ask: have we done everything, have we ticked all the boxes, have we looked at everything properly? And only then move on, rather than doing things quickly, easily and cheaply. That is always something that still tends to creep in. But cost savings can come from other things too. They do not have to be limited to the price of the product.

Sigrid Mulders Yes. If you can achieve so much better performance under certain circumstances, that should be valued more. That is where durability and sustainability come together too. The Dutch word makes that difficult. As you just said, Pierre, there are circumstances in which a more durable and sustainable mix performs better. So we come back to performance-based concrete. Just look for what you need, where you need it, and who you need, where. It is a process we are all right in the middle of.

Roel van Gils But anyway, the technology is there, or at least, that is what I say.

Responsibility in the supply chain

Pierre Hendrikx Increasingly so. Be aware of where you are in the process too. Where do you stand as a player in the supply chain, what responsibility do you have, and what choices are still available to you? And when you make a choice, remember that it limits the choices available to the next player. You say the tanker is turning around. Sometimes I feel the tanker is turning more because of the current than because we are all playing our part on board.

Gerard Roelofsen Yes. Two captains at the same wheel, both pulling in different directions.

Pierre Hendrikx So to speak. To turn a ship around, you need someone to limit the engine power, someone to set the course, someone to actually turn the wheel, and someone to take care of a bit of maintenance, so that the ship does not break down halfway through the turn. If we keep that process in mind, we should recognise that we have a position in it and that our choices have a real impact on the outcome. We cannot just assume that the person after us will sort it out.

Sigrid Mulders That is very true. If you are the client and you do not ask for it, not much will happen. But if you are the supplier and you do not offer it… You really need each other, and you need to ask each other the right questions.

Gerard Roelofsen You also need to challenge each other with new products or new ways of thinking. Sometimes that leads to something, sometimes it does not. But you have to keep moving. If you stand still, you will not get anywhere.

Vincent van der Plas Often, much more is possible than you think. Once the requirements are clear, you can all look together at what alternatives are available and what solutions you can offer. So far, that has shown that much more is possible than we thought.

Sigrid Mulders That is what I find really great.

Gerard Roelofsen We are still surprised almost every week by what is possible and what new things are being added.

Vincent van der Plas There are so many new things on the market. And without pilots… We collect a lot of data from every pilot. We have it analysed by external laboratories. We check whether something really works. Does it add anything in terms of quality? Is it just a CO2 reduction? We can build on that data.

Sigrid Mulders And technically, so much is possible.

Vincent van der Plas Technically, an astonishing amount is possible.

Sigrid Mulders But above all, we need to get on with it.

Vincent van der Plas Yes, give it attention.

Pierre Hendrikx Understand that a concrete wall is part of a building and that its quality is determined on site. It takes site managers to build it. If you understand that, really consider the whole process. It could just as easily be at the Eemshaven, so to speak, on the quayside. Cement, raw materials and admixtures will take care of themselves. But really think of it as a wall in a building, with an XC1 and a C30/37 or a C20/25. And act accordingly.

Collaboration as the common thread

Roel van Gils Right. So collaboration is the common thread running through this discussion. Thank you all very much for taking part.

Sigrid Mulders Thank you for inviting me.

Pierre Hendrikx Yes, thank you all.

Gerard Roelofsen Thank you.

Vincent van der Plas Thank you.

Bedrijven in dit verhaal

Blijf dit volgen

Bij een nieuw verhaal krijg je een e-mail. Geen account nodig.

Wat je volgt
  • ThemaMinder CO2 in beton en staal
  • OnderwerpGeneral
  • BedrijfSika Nederland B.V.
Deel dit artikel

Advertentie

Volgen op Beton & Staalbouw

Volg

Bij een project of bedrijf krijg je een e-mail zodra er een nieuw verhaal over verschijnt, bij een thema of onderwerp één keer per week een overzicht. Geen account en geen wachtwoord: in elke mail staat een link naar wat je volgt.