General

Building Art or Visual Art

Milad Pallesh, Architect/oprichter van Studio Pallesh
Milad Pallesh, Architect/oprichter van Studio Pallesh

The architect’s role in the building process has been shifting for years. Who still practises the art of building, mastering the full range of the craft? Architects, and young architects in particular, are now mainly brought in for ‘quick wins’. A good story, flashy diagrams, an attractive image and, above all, plenty of greenery. Lots and lots of greenery! Or, as Petra Blaisse puts it, ‘dripping greenery’. If we are not careful, we are all getting better at creating images and diagrams, but worse at producing a good architectural detail. That is not what true building art is about, is it?

The focus on speed, returns and ticking off lists of sustainability scores threatens to erode the mastery of the art of building, even though architecture is a building art, not a visual art. Building and art: these two words encapsulate the pursuit of beauty through craftsmanship. Unfortunately, it is often hard to find in the average building project, including housing. Where is the love of aesthetics? Should beauty, however subjective, not carry as much weight in the spreadsheets as a building’s return? Herman Zeinstra once taught me that architecture ‘should move your heart’. These days, very few new buildings in the Netherlands actually stir any emotion in me. What I mainly see is a profession constrained by rules, and a drive to create buildings as efficiently as possible. 

In my view, practising the art of building is not a luxury but a necessity. To quote the French architect and theorist Julien Guadet of the French École des Beaux-Arts: architecture begins with a design, followed by study, then construction. In this process, ‘building’ is the ultimate aim of the design and study. Guadet wrote about this more than 121 years ago: ‘Building must always come first for the architect: it is the source of his means, and it is also where his limitations lie. Attempts at architecture that cannot be built do not count.’ This sounds so simple, but in practice it is not. If architects are not given the chance to develop the craft side of their profession, our knowledge and skills will dwindle, and the field as a whole will suffer. In that case, the architect is reduced to a designer who gets to choose a colour for the window frames from the RAL colour chart.

It is now almost unrealistic to expect to be given a full commission as an architect. You can count yourself lucky if you are allowed to produce a preliminary design plus, and, if you are fortunate, are given an aesthetic supervisory role in the crucial stages that follow. There is a reason why clients call (young) architects and ask the rhetorical question: ‘How do you see your role in the building process?’ The answer is clear, but they are generally not interested in a subjective argument. At the same time, contractors and consultants are taking on an increasingly large share of the building process. To each their own, but I would argue that architects should once again have an integrated role in the building process, from design to handover. Not as a drafting office, but as a full-fledged member of the project team. 

Everyone says, ‘Building is a team effort!’, but for now it is often the designers who are no longer allowed to take part halfway through the game.   

Milad Pallesh
Architect/founder of Studio Pallesh

Vraag over dit verhaal? Stel je vraag

Blijf dit volgen

Bij een nieuw verhaal krijg je een e-mail. Geen account nodig.

Wat je volgt
  • OnderwerpGeneral
Deel dit artikel

Advertentie

Volgen op Beton & Staalbouw

Volg

Bij een project of bedrijf krijg je een e-mail zodra er een nieuw verhaal over verschijnt, bij een thema of onderwerp één keer per week een overzicht. Geen account en geen wachtwoord: in elke mail staat een link naar wat je volgt.