Concrete really isn’t so bad after all!

Compared with not building at all, putting up houses, offices, apartment blocks, factories and other structures is always bad for the environment, regardless of whether you use concrete, brick or timber. Yet building with concrete is more environmentally friendly than you might think. In the Netherlands, concrete accounts for just 1.6 per cent of CO2 emissions, even when cement and reinforcing steel production abroad is included. When concrete is made, cement is the material responsible for most CO2 emissions. Around 80 per cent of total carbon dioxide emissions come from cement. The rest of the CO2 emissions are generated by energy used for transport and production.
Four questions about concrete
People claim that building with concrete is bad for the environment, but is that really true?
The 1.6 per cent share is low, especially considering that concrete makes up three-quarters of the mass of building materials used in residential and non-residential construction in our country. Its contribution to carbon dioxide emissions here is relatively small, but it must still be brought down to zero. The European cement industry has committed to achieving zero emissions by 2050.
Worldwide, concrete accounts for seven per cent of total CO2 emissions. This is due to enormous demand, and there is a good reason for it: concrete is strong and safe, lasts a very long time and can be used to make almost anything, from towering skyscrapers, homes, sewers, bridges and industrial floors to much more.

Building with concrete is more environmentally friendly than building with timber. How can that be?
At first glance, building with timber may seem to result in lower CO2 emissions, but closer examination shows that this is not the case. Incidentally, timber used in construction is often CLT, or Cross-Laminated Timber. This is glued laminated timber sourced from plantation forests. Its production requires adhesives and resins containing substances such as polyurethane and melamine-formaldehyde. Protective coatings are also used in its application. To improve its fire resistance, it needs to be clad or made from thicker timber. CLT is therefore quite different from a freshly sawn, wonderfully fragrant beam straight from the forest.
For a fair comparison, it is best to look at the building level. Values per kilogram or tonne are less useful and difficult to compare in practice, because a building requires a greater volume of CLT than concrete. On the other hand, a cubic metre of concrete is much heavier than glued timber.
Studies show that, at the building level, concrete performs better than or comparably to CLT in terms of its CO2 footprint. But that is not the whole story. A timber building requires more energy for heating and cooling than its concrete equivalent. In a timber home, the additional heating and cooling alone over a period of 15 years generate as much CO2 as the concrete production for a comparable home.

What studies are these?
These are independent studies conducted in Belgium, Sweden and Norway. The study in our southern neighbour found no environmental difference between a concrete house and one made from conventional structural timber. For an 8-storey apartment building, concrete performs 10 per cent better. The Norwegian study shows that, in terms of CO2 emissions, concrete performs better than CLT for a 16-storey apartment building, performs about equally for 8 storeys, and is slightly less favourable than CLT for 4 storeys. One small caveat: the Norwegians assumed a clinker content of 70 per cent for concrete, which is higher than in the Netherlands. Here, the clinker content is 50 per cent.
What does the LCA say about concrete?
The LCA, or Life Cycle Assessment, provides considerable insight into environmental impacts and associated CO2 emissions, but there are some caveats. The LCA takes 11 key aspects into account to arrive at a single figure: the Environmental Cost Indicator (MKI). This expresses in euros the cost of compensating for adverse environmental impacts. In the Netherlands, the MKI scores for all materials used in a building are combined to produce what is known as the MPG, or Environmental Performance of Buildings.
The life cycle assessment does not measure everything. For example, it does not account for organic material left behind, such as after trees are felled. In addition, although CO2 absorption and emissions are rightly offset against each other, a tree would have absorbed much more CO2 had it not been felled. The increase in biodiversity in river areas resulting from sand and gravel extraction is not included in the LCA. The service life of concrete is also estimated very conservatively for the analysis: 50 years for offices and 75 for homes, even though they can easily last for more than a century.
Vraag over dit verhaal? Stel je vraag
Blijf dit volgen
Bij een nieuw verhaal krijg je een e-mail. Geen account nodig.
- OnderwerpGeneral


















