Concrete and steel in a legal perspective
Tekst Joost HaestBeeld Severijn Hulshof Advocaten

Pouring concrete in the rain and legal disputes
Pouring concrete in the rain need not be a problem. It generally only becomes an issue when heavy rain dilutes the concrete mix or creates craters. But what if concrete is poured in heavy rain and defects subsequently arise? This inevitably leads to a number of legal disputes.
A recent ruling by the Netherlands Arbitration Institute for the Construction Industry on 23 August 2023 (no. 37.601) is a striking example of such disputes. The issues considered include (i) the warranty given by the subcontractor, (ii) the quality of the concrete supplied by the main contractor, (iii) the subcontractor’s claim that the main contractor required the concrete to be poured despite the rain, and (iv) the main contractor’s approval of the concrete work.
The case concerned concrete work for the substructure of an underground car park and a tunnel as part of a new-build development of 35 apartments. The Stabu Standard 2012 and UAV 2012 applied to the project. After handover, the surface layer of the access ramp had worn away, exposing the heating pipes and causing the surface layer to crumble. The main contractor had also discovered voids in the ramp, which meant that, in its view, repairing the surface layer alone would not be sufficient. It also emerged that there was a construction joint in places between the base layer and the surface layer of the ramp.
Wear to the surface layer
The arbitrator begins by finding that, under the warranty given, the subcontractor is required to repair defects in the ramp at its own expense upon first notification, unless it can demonstrate that the defects are not attributable to it. The subcontractor does not dispute that it provided a warranty, but argues that the defects are not attributable to it.
The first dispute concerned the quality of the concrete supplied by the main contractor. The arbitrator finds that email correspondence shows that the main contractor supplied C30/37 XC3 concrete for the surface layer of the ramp. This concrete is generally suitable, and the subcontractor has not demonstrated that the concrete supplied was defective. This quickly resolved the issue.
The subcontractor then argues that the defects in the ramp arose because the main contractor insisted that it pour the surface layer even though it was raining on the scheduled pour date. The rain was much heavier than forecast, preventing the surface layer from curing properly and washing the quartz out of the fresh concrete.
The arbitrator considers it plausible that the surface layer was damaged during the work as a result of pouring in heavy rain. This was a workmanship error for which the subcontractor is liable, irrespective of the warranty. In response to the main contractor’s denial, the subcontractor has not demonstrated that the main contractor in any way compelled it to pour the ramp as scheduled despite the rainfall forecast in the weather reports. It is above all the subcontractor’s responsibility to decide whether the weather conditions are suitable for the work to be carried out at that time. If they are not, it must either refrain from carrying out the work or take appropriate measures to prevent damage, for example by erecting a tent over the pour. According to the arbitrator, the fact that the main contractor’s QA/QC manager approved the subcontractor’s work both before the pour and after it had been completed does not alter this.
The arbitrator rules that the subcontractor is liable for the defects in the surface layer of the ramp and must repair them under the warranty.
Construction joint
Although there should generally be no construction joints, the arbitrator finds no indication that this joint will affect the service life and/or functionality of the ramp. The claim for repair of the joint or any compensation is therefore dismissed.
Voids in the concrete
An expert report submitted in evidence concludes that voids are present in 1% to 3% of the ramp surface. In principle, the concrete should have been placed during construction in such a way that no significant voids remained. The mere presence of voids could therefore perhaps formally be classified as a defect, according to the arbitrator. However, the size and number of the voids identified are so limited that they do not affect the ramp’s service life or functionality. These voids are not as large as those discovered earlier, which were probably caused by the hydrodemolition used to repair the existing heating pipes, as the subcontractor had consistently maintained.
Even if the small voids in the concrete can be classified as defects, the client’s interest in having them repaired does not justify the associated costs. And as the voids have caused no damage, no compensation can be awarded in respect of this item either.
Conclusion
Although the subcontractor is not held responsible for repairing the construction joint or the voids in the concrete, it must repair the surface layer. A competent and diligent contractor could have prevented this by either not pouring during the heavy downpour, taking precautions such as erecting a tent, or recording in writing that the main contractor had insisted that the pour go ahead despite the rain and the lack of protective measures.
Joost Haest Severijn Hulshof advocaten
Vraag over dit verhaal? Stel je vraag
Blijf dit volgen
Bij een nieuw verhaal krijg je een e-mail. Geen account nodig.
- ThemaNormen, testen en aansprakelijkheid
- OnderwerpGeneral


















