General

Concrete & steel in a legal context

Tekst Joost HaestBeeld Severijn Hulshof advocaten

Joost Haest, Severijn Hulshof advocaten
Joost Haest, Severijn Hulshof advocaten

Concrete and steel, procurement and RAW

When work in the concrete and steel sector is put out to tender, a RAW specification is used in many cases. The RAW system includes specific provisions for tenders, including provisions that must be observed, failing which a tender will be invalid. Case law shows that these specific RAW provisions regularly lead to legal proceedings, with the outcome often being unfavourable for the tenderer. Such disputes can be avoided if tenderers are familiar with these RAW provisions. In this column, I discuss the specific RAW provisions for tenders, drawing on a very recent tender ruling concerning sewerage works. 

In a ruling by the Noord-Holland District Court dated 7 February 2024, the case concerned a European open procedure to award a framework agreement for cleaning and inspecting sewers. The 2020 Standard RAW Provisions had been declared applicable.

Include all costs in the unit rate

A key principle when tendering on the basis of the Standard RAW Provisions is that tenderers must include in each unit rate all costs required to fulfil the performance obligation. For framework agreements, this is set out in 01.01.06 paragraph 02 [1] of the Standard RAW Provisions. 

In this case, the contracting authority checked whether the provisional winning tender complied with this obligation. The contracting authority is required to carry out this check under Article 01.01.07 paragraph 01 of the Standard RAW Provisions [2]. The check found that a considerable number of unit rates deviated from the estimate drawn up by the contracting authority. This could indicate that the tenderer had not complied with the obligation outlined above to include all costs in the unit rate. The contracting authority therefore asked the provisional winner to explain a number of unit rates. The provisional winner was then given seven calendar days to provide a written explanation. This mandatory verification procedure follows from Article 01.01.07 paragraph 02 of the Standard RAW Provisions [3].

Rate for flushing truck unrealistic

During the verification meeting, it emerged that the provisional winner had used an unrealistic unit rate for deploying a so-called flushing truck. The provisional winner responded that the unit rate was realistic if the flushing truck was used in combination with a sewer-cleaning vehicle and a vacuum truck. That explanation settled the matter immediately. In effect, the provisional winner was stating that 1) not all the costs for the flushing truck had been included in the unit rate and 2) some of the costs for the flushing truck had been shifted to the sewer-cleaning vehicle and the vacuum truck. The preliminary relief judge ruled, correctly, that this did not comply with the obligation under Article 01.01.06 paragraph 02 of the Standard RAW Provisions. Under Article 01.01.07 paragraph 03 of the Standard RAW Provisions, the contracting authority was therefore required to reject the tender as invalid. 

The provisional winner’s comment that it was willing to bear any loss on the unit rate for the flushing truck itself was also decidedly ill-advised. Aside from the fact that this comment once again confirmed that not all costs had been included in the unit rate, it effectively amounted to a statement that the provisional winner was offering a discount in the unit rate. Under Article 01.01.06 paragraph 03 [4] of the Standard RAW Provisions, tenderers are not permitted to include a discount in a unit rate. Any discount must instead be stated separately in the overall costs.

Rate for traffic controllers unrealistic

The contracting authority also found that the provisional winner had used the same unit rate for two traffic controllers as for deploying four traffic controllers. As a result, the unit rate for the specification item covering four traffic controllers, when converted to a rate for one traffic controller, came to such a low amount (€13.75 per traffic controller) that it was clear that this rate could not possibly include all the costs either. The provisional winner explained that it had made a calculation error for this specification item. This explanation also immediately invalidated the tender. The preliminary relief judge ruled, correctly, that this was not an obvious error that could be easily rectified. The provisional winner’s argument that the contracting authority could have inferred from the stated unit rate for two traffic controllers that the rate for four simply needed to be doubled was rejected. The unit rate for two traffic controllers could just as easily have contained an error. Moreover, adjusting the unit rate for four traffic controllers would also change the total tender price, which is not permitted. 

For this unit rate too, the provisional winner stated that it was willing to bear any loss on the rate for four traffic controllers itself. But, as with the flushing truck, the preliminary relief judge held that this amounted to a discount on the unit rate, which is not permitted under the RAW system.

Take note

This ruling clearly shows that tenderers must comply with the RAW system in RAW tenders. Failure to do so will result in exclusion. Tenderers, take note.

A critical comment on the RAW system is warranted. The total tender price may be entirely in line with the market and reasonable, yet a tender can still be declared invalid on the basis of just one unit rate that fails to meet the RAW system requirements or contains a calculation error. This feels like a very harsh penalty, emotionally, commercially and legally.

Joost Haest
Severijn Hulshof advocaten

Vraag over dit verhaal? Stel je vraag

Blijf dit volgen

Bij een nieuw verhaal krijg je een e-mail. Geen account nodig.

Wat je volgt
  • ThemaNormen, testen en aansprakelijkheid
  • OnderwerpGeneral
Deel dit artikel

Advertentie

Volgen op Beton & Staalbouw

Volg

Bij een project of bedrijf krijg je een e-mail zodra er een nieuw verhaal over verschijnt, bij een thema of onderwerp één keer per week een overzicht. Geen account en geen wachtwoord: in elke mail staat een link naar wat je volgt.