Concrete & steel in a legal perspective
Beeld Severijn Hulshof advocaten

In my legal column for Beton & Staalbouw, I always try to draw as much as possible on relevant cases from practice. This time, I discuss a very recent ruling by the Arbitration Board for Construction Disputes dated 24 May 2024 (no. 37.677) concerning ‘pop-outs’ in supplied precast concrete walls.
Pop-outs are small fragments of concrete that break away from the concrete surface. This damage is caused by contaminants in the concrete, which swell over time as a result of chemical reactions or water absorption. The case concerned pop-outs in precast concrete wall elements in 57 newly built rental homes. There were between dozens and several thousand pop-outs per home, predominantly measuring 1 to 9 mm.
Cause of the damage
Opinions on the cause of the damage were divided for a long time. The client initially claimed that the pop-outs were caused by the presence of old wood in the concrete. A subsequent expert report commissioned by the client concluded that the pop-outs were caused by the damage mechanism known as alkali-carbonate reaction (ACR). This is a chemical reaction in concrete in which silicates from aggregates react with alkaline substances in the concrete to form alkali-silica gel. This absorbs water, causing the concrete to swell, develop crazing-like cracks and shed particles.
Further investigation by the supplier concluded that the pop-outs were not caused by ACR, but by reactive particles (calcium oxide, or quicklime) in the powder fraction, very probably originating from the pulverised coal fly ash present. The arbitrators concur with the supplier’s conclusion, but immediately note that the underlying cause is essentially irrelevant. The consequences are in any event at the supplier’s risk and expense. This decision rests on a number of steps.
Supplier’s liability
Under Article 6 of the conditions applicable to the contract for the manufacture and supply of precast concrete elements, the supplier was required to produce the concrete walls as ‘smooth, flat-finished grey reinforced vibrated concrete’. Under a warranty declaration issued, the supplier is liable for ten years after the end of the maintenance period to remedy, at its own risk and expense and upon first notice, any defects and consequential damage that arise, unless the supplier proves that those defects are not its responsibility. The warranty includes a guarantee that the walls supplied comply with the requirements set out in the contract and are suitable for their intended purpose. It is also stipulated that all work carried out by the supplier must comply with the requirements of the Woningborg Guarantee and Warranty Scheme 2010. In view of this, the concrete walls must meet the standards of good and proper workmanship. The arbitrators consider these provisions to be the crux of the matter.
Given the nature and extent of the pop-outs, the arbitrators consider that the walls do not meet the requirements set out in the contract or the standards of good and proper workmanship, and are not suitable for their intended purpose. The supplier’s liability is therefore established. The supplier argued that the pop-outs could not be avoided because natural products that may be present in concrete elements were involved. The arbitrators considered that this did not provide a defence against liability for such a large number of pop-outs. Nor were the causes external.
Contrary to the supplier’s argument, it was not the client’s responsibility to include quality requirements or specific guarantees concerning the avoidance of pop-outs. That is only relevant in the case of fair-faced concrete, where the occurrence of pop-outs must be kept to a minimum. The arbitrators also note that a few pop-outs would not have given rise to liability, but the sheer number of pop-outs does.
Remedial method
Initially, the client considered that the pop-outs could be repaired by drilling them out and filling the resulting holes, at a cost of € 242,000,-. As a very large number of pop-outs subsequently appeared, the client argued that this method of repair was no longer practical. The arbitrators agreed. The client then claimed for repairs by installing plasterboard walls, and for 57 apartments the claim quickly rose to € 672,000,-.
The supplier argued that the tenants could finish the walls with thick, heavy-duty wallpaper, which would conceal the pop-outs. The arbitrators rejected this argument. Given the damage mechanism, whereby pieces of concrete are forced off the wall surface, it is sufficiently plausible that heavy-duty wallpaper would not provide a proper and lasting solution. The pop-outs would show through. Moreover, this would restrict the tenants’ choice of wall finish in a way that cannot reasonably be expected of them. The arbitrators consider it sufficiently plausible that a proper and lasting solution can be achieved by installing plasterboard on the concrete walls, allowing tenants to choose between painting, wallpapering or plastering the walls.
The fact that the supplier did not contractually limit its liability to the contract value, and that the damage substantially exceeds that value, is not sufficient to limit the supplier’s obligation to pay damages.
Amount awarded
On the basis of the foregoing, the client’s claim is upheld, although not in full. The client included a claim for € 205,000,- in damages for the alleged need to carry out interim repairs to the plasterboard. The client argued that, during the remaining service life of the apartments, the tenants would replace the plasterboard finish several times, each time requiring local repairs to the plasterboard’s surface layer. The arbitrators ruled that it had not been established that the housing association would be liable to its tenants for damage to the plasterboard if the tenants themselves replaced its finish in the future. This part of the client’s claim was therefore rejected.
Of the € 672,000,- claimed, € 466,000,- is therefore awarded, plus interest, legal costs and extrajudicial costs. The total comes to more than half a million euros. A very expensive and instructive lesson for the supplier.
Joost Haest,
lawyer at Severijn Hulshof advocaten
Vraag over dit verhaal? Stel je vraag
Blijf dit volgen
Bij een nieuw verhaal krijg je een e-mail. Geen account nodig.
- ThemaNormen, testen en aansprakelijkheid
- OnderwerpGeneral


















