General

Concrete & Steel from a legal perspective

Tekst en beeld Joost Haest, Severijn Hulshof advocaten

Joost Haest, Severijn Hulshof advocaten
Joost Haest, Severijn Hulshof advocaten

In Beton & Staalbouw 3 of 2023, I wrote about the interim judgment of the District Court of the Northern Netherlands (ECLI:NL:RBNNE:2023:1083) concerning the Waterschap Rijn en IJssel office building with a bubble-deck floor, where the debate centred on whether there was a serious defect or a risk of collapse. The court ruled that the client had not (yet) demonstrated that there was such a serious defect. This was therefore a positive outcome for the contractor. However, the court also ruled that, in order to determine whether there was a serious defect, it needed an independent and impartial expert report. This posed a risk for the contractor, since if that independent report were to conclude that there was indeed a serious defect, the contractor would still be liable. The contractor therefore lodged an interlocutory appeal, arguing that the Waterschap had failed to discharge its burden of proving that there was a serious defect. It succeeded: in a judgment dated 21 January 2025, the Arnhem-Leeuwarden Court of Appeal dismissed the client’s claims (ECLI:NL:GHARL:2025:186). 

In its judgment, the Court of Appeal states that the decisive question is whether the Waterschap has put forward sufficient evidence to support the conclusion that there is a serious defect. The Court considers the contractor’s warranty irrelevant in this context. There is no evidence that the warranty has been breached, particularly since it is undisputed that there was no poor batch or, in short, any project-specific fault in the execution.

In discussing the evidence, the Court of Appeal aptly describes the proceedings as a ‘battle of the experts’. On one side are the client’s experts, led by ABT, and on the other, the contractor’s experts, Pieters Bouwtechniek. Of particular importance is the contractor’s defence that the design chosen in 2008 was consistent with prevailing knowledge at the time, a so-called ‘state-of-the-art’ defence. This argument concerns whether the design itself was sufficiently safe, meaning that there was no serious defect. The District Court found this insufficiently clear at first instance and therefore ordered an expert assessment. The Court of Appeal focuses more on the fact that it is for the Waterschap to prove that there was a serious defect. Under paragraph 28(2)(b) of the applicable UAV-GC 2005, this requires a risk of collapse or unsuitability for the intended use.

According to the Court of Appeal, a real risk of collapse in the part of the building that is currently unused has not been established under the anticipated loading conditions. Moreover, no such loading occurs in practice. At the hearing, the Waterschap stated that the measures taken had addressed any possible risk of collapse. In the Court’s view, there is insufficient evidence that the building is unsuitable for its intended use. The Court notes that the building is not merely in temporary use: it has been in use since 2008, and it has not been alleged that this use, including after 2017, is inconsistent with the purpose for which the building was constructed. It may be true that several dozen workstations are unused and that some sections of floor are propped, but that alone does not justify the conclusion that the building is unsuitable for its intended use. The Court of Appeal therefore concludes that insufficient evidence has been put forward to justify the conclusion that there is a serious defect. The client’s claims are therefore dismissed.    

Vraag over dit verhaal? Stel je vraag

Blijf dit volgen

Bij een nieuw verhaal krijg je een e-mail. Geen account nodig.

Wat je volgt
  • ThemaNormen, testen en aansprakelijkheid
  • OnderwerpGeneral
Deel dit artikel

Advertentie

Volgen op Beton & Staalbouw

Volg

Bij een project of bedrijf krijg je een e-mail zodra er een nieuw verhaal over verschijnt, bij een thema of onderwerp één keer per week een overzicht. Geen account en geen wachtwoord: in elke mail staat een link naar wat je volgt.