General

Concrete & Steel from a legal perspective

Tekst en beeld Joost Haest, Severijn Hulshof advocaten

Joost Haest, Severijn Hulshof advocaten
Joost Haest, Severijn Hulshof advocaten

A client held liable in legal proceedings in connection with a UAV-GC project because incorrect information about the (foundation) design provided by the client was included in the tender documents. This is uncommon, but it was the outcome in a recent ruling by the Court of Appeal in Den Bosch on 21 January 2025 (ECLI:NL:GHSHE:2025:114). A ruling that merits attention. 

In these extensive proceedings, the question was which party should bear the costs of the additional work submitted by the contractor as a result of changes to the foundation design. The contractor argued that a report and drawing issued during the tender process contained information about the structural load-bearing capacity of the basement floor (its thickness and structural properties) and the ground beneath it (its composition and compaction). The client’s information also indicated that the 40-centimetre-thick basement floor formed part of the foundation and transferred loads to the ground below. The contractor based its further design development on this information, but, according to the contractor, it proved incorrect in practice, making the contractor’s proposed solution impossible to build without additional work.

Responsibility

The client mounted an extensive defence, arguing that it had not breached any duty to provide information. According to the client, under the UAV-GC contract the contractor was responsible as both designer and builder for incorrect design assumptions. The contractor should not have based its assumptions about the structural load-bearing capacity of the floor and the ground in the foundation design on the tender documents. Alternatively, it should at least have raised questions or requested further information from the client during the dialogue.

Expert

The Court first ruled, on the basis of the UAV-GC contract, that the contractor is in principle responsible for the accuracy of the design and its execution. Under the law and the UAV-GC contract, the client is responsible for incorrect information it provides, unless the contractor ought to have discovered that the information was incorrect and should have warned the client. The Court appointed an expert to address the substantive technical dispute. The expert concluded that the existing basement floor did not in fact form part of the foundation, was not 40 centimetres thick, but measured between 11 and 24 centimetres in thickness, and did not transfer loads directly to the ground everywhere, because the ground had been raised with a layer of loose, disturbed earth. As a result, the basis of the contractor’s foundation design, using the existing pad foundations and adding extra pads on the basement floor, could not be implemented without modifications such as strengthening the floor slab. 

According to the expert, a reasonably observant and properly informed structural engineer could have assumed, on the basis of the information provided by the client during the tender process, that both the pad foundations and the floor were shallow-founded. The contractor could also have assumed that the load transfer to the ground was broadly the same beneath the pads as beneath the floor. A reasonably observant and properly informed structural engineer would not, including in light of their experience, have been expected to anticipate disturbed ground that significantly limited the load-bearing capacity of the floor. Accordingly, there was no opportunity or duty to warn.

Incorrect information

The Court found the expert’s findings understandable and convincing, despite the client’s numerous and strongly worded objections, and adopted the expert’s conclusions. It therefore declared that the client had provided the contractor with incorrect information during the tender phase and was required to bear the consequences of that incorrect information. Accordingly, the client must reimburse the contractor for the cost increase of €1,010,698.00 excluding VAT.   

Vraag over dit verhaal? Stel je vraag

Blijf dit volgen

Bij een nieuw verhaal krijg je een e-mail. Geen account nodig.

Wat je volgt
  • ThemaNormen, testen en aansprakelijkheid
  • OnderwerpGeneral
Deel dit artikel

Advertentie

Volgen op Beton & Staalbouw

Volg

Bij een project of bedrijf krijg je een e-mail zodra er een nieuw verhaal over verschijnt, bij een thema of onderwerp één keer per week een overzicht. Geen account en geen wachtwoord: in elke mail staat een link naar wat je volgt.