General

Concrete & steel in legal perspective

Tekst en beeld Joost Haest, Severijn Hulshof advocaten

Concrete & steel in legal perspective

Following my earlier column for Beton & Staalbouw on a ruling concerning ‘pop-outs’ in concrete walls, published in mid-2024, this time I am once again looking at a dispute in which pop-outs were at the heart of the discussion. Whereas the 2024 proceedings focused more on the technical aspects of the pop-outs and the damage, the 2026 case focuses more on legal issues, particularly the possible limitation of the claims. Spoiler alert: in the 2024 case, the Raad van Arbitrage in Bouwgeschillen (ruling of 24 May 2024, no. 37.677) held that the contractor was liable for the pop-outs. In the recent case before the Rechtbank Rotterdam (ruling of 21 January 2026, ECLI:NL:RBROT:2026:540), the contractor was likewise found liable.

Pop-outs after handover

After handover of a new-build development, defects in the form of ‘pop-outs’ appeared in the concrete walls of 31 homes owned by private individuals. Pop-outs are small pieces of concrete that detach from the concrete surface, leaving pits and uneven areas. This damage is caused by contaminants in the concrete, which swell over time as a result of chemical reactions or water absorption. The number of pop-outs decreases over time, but this process can continue for years. The homes were handed over in 2018, and the SWK Garantie- en waarborgregeling 2014 applies to the construction contracts.

Between 2020 and 2022, several owners complained to the contractor about so-called ‘pop-outs’. In February 2022, the contractor presented a timetable for a solution and stated that earlier repair work had not yet produced results. The contractor then investigated suitable repair methods in March 2023 by inspecting each home. In June 2023, the contractor offered compensation for each home, based on all the walls assessed. A draft settlement agreement was also enclosed. At the end of June 2023, the contractor responded to the owners’ questions, stating that, according to an independent investigation in 2020, the pop-outs were caused by contaminated fly ash in the concrete walls. The contractor also sent the final report following the assessment of the walls. In July 2023, the owners held the contractor liable for a breach of contract attributable to it. In August 2023, the contractor denied liability.

Limitation defence

In the proceedings, the contractor argued that the owners’ claims were time-barred. According to the contractor, the five-year limitation period under Article 15(6) of the Algemene Voorwaarden SWK, which applies to hidden defects, had expired because proceedings had not been initiated within five years of handover. The contractor also argued that, under Article 7:761(1) of the Dutch Civil Code, the claims were time-barred because the complaints dated from 2020 and early 2021, while the summons was not served within the following two years, but only in December 2024. The court rejected the contractor’s defence.

The court found that the contractor was aware of the pop-out problem in 2020 and 2021. It was also established that the contractor had visited the claimants to investigate the problem itself. Finally, it was established that the contractor had been able to form a clear picture of the problem, since it subsequently offered individual financial compensation. The court therefore saw no reasonable and legally protectable interest of the contractor that would have been harmed by a strict finding that the time limits cited by the contractor had been breached. The contractor was unable to explain or clarify this at the hearing.

In the court’s view, the foregoing means that, even if the contractual forfeiture periods relied on by the contractor had been breached, invoking them would be unacceptable according to the standards of reasonableness and fairness (Article 6:248(2) of the Dutch Civil Code). In this case, the interests of the claimants, all private individuals, outweigh those of the professional contractor. A successful reliance on the provisions in question would mean that the claimants’ claims were inadmissible, even though the parties do not dispute what the problems are and they can still be reassessed, despite the passage of time. It is also relevant that, following its own investigation into the pop-out problem, the contractor established that damage had occurred and offered the owners financial compensation.

The limitation defence under Article 7:761(1) of the Dutch Civil Code was also rejected. The court held that the two-year limitation period begins only when a period for repairs set by the client expires, or earlier if the contractor has stated that it will not repair the defect. After receiving complaints in 2020 and 2021, the contractor investigated possible repairs. It was not until June 2023 that the contractor stated that it would not carry out repairs. The limitation period therefore began only then, meaning that the summons in December 2024 was served in time and the claims were not time-barred. In other words, the 2024 and 2026 rulings show that pop-outs are a problem contractors need to take seriously.

Vraag over dit verhaal? Stel je vraag

Blijf dit volgen

Bij een nieuw verhaal krijg je een e-mail. Geen account nodig.

Wat je volgt
  • ThemaNormen, testen en aansprakelijkheid
  • OnderwerpGeneral
Deel dit artikel

Advertentie

Volgen op Beton & Staalbouw

Volg

Bij een project of bedrijf krijg je een e-mail zodra er een nieuw verhaal over verschijnt, bij een thema of onderwerp één keer per week een overzicht. Geen account en geen wachtwoord: in elke mail staat een link naar wat je volgt.