General

Concrete and steel from a legal perspective

Tekst Severijn Hulshof AdvocatenFotografie Severijn Hulshof Advocaten

Joost Haest.
Joost Haest.

The extreme price rises caused by the effects of the war in Ukraine have already led to numerous legal disputes. One of these disputes concerns whether a contractor must continue to fulfil its obligations at the agreed prices, or whether it may suspend performance until agreement has been reached on price increases. This issue has now led to a number of court rulings clarifying the rights and obligations of businesses in such circumstances. The most notable ruling, which has also received extensive media coverage, was handed down by the preliminary relief judge of the Lelystad District Court on 8 September 2022 (ECLI:NL:RBMNE:2022:3592). It concerned the supply of ready-mixed concrete for the foundations of 45 wind turbines. Here is a brief legal analysis, with an important conclusion for the market.

Price rises in ready-mixed concrete

In December 2021, the ready-mixed concrete supplier entered into an agreement with a main contractor responsible for building 45 wind turbines. As a result of the war in Ukraine, the supplier was faced with huge price rises in mid-2022. The supplier threatened to suspend deliveries unless the contractor promptly paid the invoices relating to the price increases. The contractor then asked the preliminary relief judge to order the supplier to continue deliveries, arguing that the announced suspension was unlawful and would have serious consequences for the progress of the entire project. 

The supplier’s general terms and conditions included a clause allowing it to pass on increased costs to the customer. The judge found that it had not been established that the parties had agreed that the supplier’s general terms and conditions would take precedence. The preliminary relief judge therefore concluded that the supplier could not rely on this specific clause and could not pass on the price increases unilaterally. This also meant that the supplier had no claim against the contractor for the price increases that was due and payable. The supplier was therefore not entitled to suspend deliveries. The preliminary relief judge accordingly ruled that the contractor was right to demand performance of the agreement. 

If the supplier refused to continue deliveries despite the judgment, it would be fined € 100.000,- per day, up to a maximum of € 2 million.  

At the hearing, the supplier also asked the preliminary relief judge to amend the agreement (that is, the prices) on the grounds of unforeseen circumstances (Article 6:258 of the Dutch Civil Code). Quite apart from the fact that the claim was brought too late, the preliminary relief judge held that such a claim could not be brought in summary proceedings, but only in substantive proceedings. 

Other case law

A ruling by the preliminary relief judge in Haarlem on 16 December 2022 (ECLI:NL:RBNHO:2022:11110) confirmed that a contractor is still obliged to fulfil its obligations despite the enormous price increases. In a ruling dated 21 July 2022, no. 37.456, the Council of Arbitration for Construction Disputes also held that a claim for additional payment due to exceptionally high cost increases is separate from the contractor’s obligation to fulfil its obligations.

Conclusion for the market

The case law outlined above shows that businesses need to be very cautious about suspending, or threatening to suspend, their obligations in disputes over price increases. The most obvious way to obtain compensation for price rises is to enter into discussions with the client, taking reasonableness and fairness into account. If that does not lead to a solution, substantive court proceedings are generally the appropriate route, rather than summary proceedings.

Joost Haest

Severijn Hulshof advocaten   

Vraag over dit verhaal? Stel je vraag

Blijf dit volgen

Bij een nieuw verhaal krijg je een e-mail. Geen account nodig.

Wat je volgt
  • ThemaNormen, testen en aansprakelijkheid
  • OnderwerpGeneral
Deel dit artikel

Advertentie

Volgen op Beton & Staalbouw

Volg

Bij een project of bedrijf krijg je een e-mail zodra er een nieuw verhaal over verschijnt, bij een thema of onderwerp één keer per week een overzicht. Geen account en geen wachtwoord: in elke mail staat een link naar wat je volgt.