General

Concrete & Steel: a legal perspective

Tekst Joost Haest, Severijn Hulshof advocatenBeeld Joost Haest

Joost Haest, advocaat bij Severijn Hulshof advocaten.
Joost Haest, advocaat bij Severijn Hulshof advocaten.

Discussions about the risk of steel price increases and their scale are commonplace, and regularly feature in legal rulings. In this context, a recent ruling by the Arbitration Board on 6 September 2024 (case number 37.708) is particularly interesting. Not only because of the scale of the project (662 million) and the size of the claim brought by the contractors’ consortium (17 million), but especially because of the arbitrators’ decision on how the agreements made between the parties should be interpreted. This includes how to determine the amount for which the contractors’ consortium is buying off the risk of steel price increases.

When tendering the project, the State wanted price certainty for the steel item. Initially, the State asked bidders to buy off this item, meaning that they would tender a fixed price for the steel to be used. When the bidders said they could not take on this risk and asked for the steel item to be indexed, the State decided to defer the buy-off to a later date, specifically no later than 6 months after the date of final award. An annex stipulated that CROW product groups 18 (reinforcing steel) and 19 (steel) would be adjusted for the 6-month period between tender submission and the buy-off date. It did not specify which index should be used for the adjustment.

The State argues that the adjustment must be made using the CROW indices for product groups 18 and 19, since the agreement refers to adjustments for CROW product groups. In addition, the contract specifies that other product groups must be adjusted using the indices applicable to those CROW product groups. The contractors’ consortium’s claim for reinforcing steel is based on indexation using the Platts index, and its claim for steel on the Grymafer index. The consortium argues that naming CROW product groups in the specific annex does not automatically mean that the CROW indices also apply. 

The arbitrators agree with the contractors’ consortium. The wording of the annex does not indicate that the CROW indices for product groups 18 and 19 must be used. The reference to CROW product groups 18 and 19 serves to clarify which materials are eligible for price adjustments, not how those price changes are to be determined. In short, no indexation method was specified.

The arbitrators begin by noting that, by including a specific provision for steel indexation, the State showed that it wished to establish a scheme for steel that differed in nature from the indexation regimes for the other product groups. The steel buy-off provision does not refer to a CROW index to be used for the buy-off, whereas the provisions for the other product groups expressly refer to the CROW indices. The arbitrators also consider that the contractors’ consortium was right to point out that the Memorandum of Information stated that the purpose of the relevant provision in the annex was to make the risk of steel price increases manageable for bidders during the period between tender submission and buy-off. According to the consortium, this risk is manageable if the successful contractor is free to price the risk of steel price increases using an index that enables it to manage the risk it actually faces across the entire project.

The arbitrators therefore find that the consortium was free under the annex to use the Platts index and the Grymafer index. The consortium was prepared to cover the risk for the duration of the project in accordance with those indices. That is its risk, and the method used does not appear unreasonable to the arbitrators. The Platts index, for example, is particularly suitable because it also incorporates an analysis of future expectations. The arbitrators therefore award the contractors’ consortium the full amount of its claim, 17 million euros. 

This ruling once again shows how important it is to clearly specify which agreements and indices the parties intend to use for steel indexation.  

Vraag over dit verhaal? Stel je vraag

Blijf dit volgen

Bij een nieuw verhaal krijg je een e-mail. Geen account nodig.

Wat je volgt
  • OnderwerpGeneral
Deel dit artikel

Advertentie

Volgen op Beton & Staalbouw

Volg

Bij een project of bedrijf krijg je een e-mail zodra er een nieuw verhaal over verschijnt, bij een thema of onderwerp één keer per week een overzicht. Geen account en geen wachtwoord: in elke mail staat een link naar wat je volgt.