General

You can learn from participation

Jeroen Atteveld – Architect | Partner bij heren 5 architecten
Jeroen Atteveld – Architect | Partner bij heren 5 architecten

Jeroen Atteveld: Architect | Partner at heren 5 architecten

I’ve noticed that engaging with local residents is becoming increasingly important in the construction projects we work on. This is not only because participation has become a cornerstone of the Environment and Planning Act, but even more because more and more projects in the Netherlands are being built within existing village or urban settings. Many residents are therefore affected by construction projects in their immediate surroundings, and are involved through participation processes, which can sometimes be very intensive. I wholeheartedly welcome this. In fact, I’ve been doing it since the early days of my career as an architect, and I’ve learned a great deal from it. But what I’m finding increasingly frustrating is the influence of those who oppose projects on principle.

At heren 5, I’m working on fitting homes, village halls and electricity substations into existing surroundings at several locations across the country. Almost every week, we move from a community centre to a sports hall or town hall, most recently, we even met with 300 people in a castle!, to talk with local residents about their wishes and needs regarding what will be built in their area. This matters, because space is limited in the Netherlands and we live close together. So we have to take one another into account.

I often hear legitimate questions such as: Will I still get enough daylight? What about my privacy? And won’t this come at the expense of green space or parking? These are all important considerations that we take into account when designing new buildings. So far, so good. But increasingly, we find that reasonableness is in short supply in discussions with critical local residents, who often act solely in their own interests. They’ll buy an electric designer bike or a new Tesla, but are firmly opposed to replacing the old electricity substation in their neighbourhood. They have children looking for homes of their own, but oppose building more homes on their own street. I’m concerned that local residents can also use participation processes to obstruct projects instead of working together.

I value participation and enjoy taking part, let’s be clear about that. heren 5 is even a co-organiser of the annual Participatieparade. We draw a great deal of inspiration from conversations with residents, or “experts by experience”, as we prefer to call them. After all, they know the neighbourhood better than anyone, and through them we learn a great deal about its qualities, challenges and social networks. This enables us to create architecture that is rooted in its location.

But what if a participation process ultimately fails to produce a design with broad support? Or what if, despite an intensive participation process, there is still someone in the area who opposes the project on principle?

In the Netherlands, people can then lodge an objection or submit a formal response to the local authority, which may have to reconsider any permits it has granted. Or, taking things a step further, local residents can appeal to the court to seek a ruling in their favour. Unfortunately, we increasingly find that winning a case takes so long that projects are put on hold for years. This means it takes even longer for someone looking for a home to have their say too, and ultimately move into a suitable home. I suggest that, from now on, we learn to make a little more room for one another when participating. 

Vraag over dit verhaal? Stel je vraag

Blijf dit volgen

Bij een nieuw verhaal krijg je een e-mail. Geen account nodig.

Wat je volgt
  • OnderwerpGeneral
Deel dit artikel

Advertentie

Volgen op Beton & Staalbouw

Volg

Bij een project of bedrijf krijg je een e-mail zodra er een nieuw verhaal over verschijnt, bij een thema of onderwerp één keer per week een overzicht. Geen account en geen wachtwoord: in elke mail staat een link naar wat je volgt.