General

Simple solutions for complex problems

Simple solutions for complex problems

Signature enthusiast and Minister for Housing Hugo de Jonge travels far and wide, devotedly signing regional housing agreements that are intended to pave the way for the construction of much-needed homes. The almost sacred target of 900,000 homes by 2030 is the ultimate goal. Given current market trends, with construction costs rising or stabilising and returns falling as interest rates rise, this is an almost impossible task, best described as Sisyphean labour. I’ll give the impeccably turned-out minister this: he approaches it with boundless optimism. Unravelling the housing crisis is a Gordian knot, where solving one problem simply causes another to surface.

Guido Wierink: owner and developer at Socialex Real Estate

Market players are only too keen to help solve what the media perceive as Hugo de Jonge’s problem, and are coming up with all kinds of creative solutions. Architects design modular flexible homes with fervent passion and love, where you can turn your bathroom into an annexe for your 90-year-old mother-in-law in the blink of an eye, because all the care homes in the Netherlands are being closed down. Contractors are rapidly putting up all kinds of housing factories, which can assemble a home on site in the time it takes you to have a number two. All under the banner of faster and cheaper, because if we build faster and cheaper, the problem of those 900,000 homes will be solved in no time. 

Complete nonsense, of course. If it were that simple, we wouldn’t have a housing shortage now. The housing market is a complex interplay of housing supply and demand, shaped by centrally regulated interest rates. It is linked to a troubled land market, where speculation about land use and development programmes determines and drives up the price of land holdings. The whole system is also strongly influenced by the government, with its ambitions for affordability and sustainability. It is a Kafkaesque set-up that is difficult to steer and certainly cannot be fixed with simplistic ideas and initiatives. Architects’ modular flexible homes play to a utopian, romantic vision that does not exist. In the end, nobody wants their 90-year-old mother-in-law living right next door. They also often result in a suboptimal business case. Developers still follow the Friedmanite school of thought and will never accept a suboptimal business case. Contractors’ factory-built homes are cheap and in demand, but the one-size-fits-all approach often fails to work in the harsh realities of practice, where inner-city land holdings are often unsuitable for standard development and require tailored solutions. Such initiatives from market players are pearls before swine: well-intentioned, but ineffective in tackling the challenge we face. 

There are no simple, linear solutions to the housing shortage. Those who claim otherwise are selling a pup. This many-headed beast will have to be tackled from several angles. Flexible concepts and cheaper construction may be one or two ingredients in the recipe, but they are certainly no panacea. The Minister for Housing will also need to bring out heavier guns than his pen. Simply signing a few housing agreements or advising a wealthy friend to ‘just doesn’t do the trick’. As a shot across the bows, I see a number of possible approaches that could, individually or in combination, help deliver more homes in the short term. Set up a fund from which developers can finance the unviable element of projects, caused by rising interest rates and construction costs, on favourable terms, similar to the NOW support scheme during the coronavirus crisis. Further regulate the property market to prevent land speculation, curbing its inflationary effect on prices and, in turn, unfeasible residual land values. Bring the government’s own land holdings forward for development and restrict the scope for objections during the zoning plan and building permit procedures.

The current crisis cannot be solved with one or two measures. It will take a package of measures that addresses the various aspects of the housing market, even if these solutions make the minister even more unpopular. The past few decades have shown that soft-hearted doctors make festering housing wounds…

Vraag over dit verhaal? Stel je vraag

Blijf dit volgen

Bij een nieuw verhaal krijg je een e-mail. Geen account nodig.

Wat je volgt
  • OnderwerpGeneral
Deel dit artikel

Advertentie

Volgen op Beton & Staalbouw

Volg

Bij een project of bedrijf krijg je een e-mail zodra er een nieuw verhaal over verschijnt, bij een thema of onderwerp één keer per week een overzicht. Geen account en geen wachtwoord: in elke mail staat een link naar wat je volgt.