The Didam ruling: a curse or a blessing?

Cris Zijlmans: developer & partner at Le Clercq Projectontwikkeling
On 26 November 2021, the Supreme Court handed down an important ruling, known in practice as the ‘Didam ruling’. In short, it means that if a local authority plans to sell a property and there is more than one interested party, those parties must be given the opportunity to compete. An open selection procedure, or tender, must then be organised, based on objective, verifiable and reasonable criteria for selecting a party. For a developer whose business model is largely based on securing development opportunities directly from local authorities, as ours has been for more than 30 years, this represents a radical change of course. Previously, we could move on to the next project after delivering attractive projects through a smooth process. Now we have to compete for every project. On the other hand, we can now be considered for many more projects that would otherwise have been awarded directly to one party. There is, of course, nothing wrong with the principles of the Didam ruling, but does it also lead to better projects and, not least in this time of severe housing shortages, faster development?
Now, almost three years after the ruling, it is interesting to look back at the wide variety of selection procedures we have seen. Having taken part in dozens of tenders, with their share of disappointments, euphoric moments, overtime hours and hundreds of thousands of euros, we have seen local authorities issue every kind of brief imaginable. From fully prescriptive selection guidelines running to hundreds of pages to a few pages of vague principles. From straightforward bids for land to briefs in which the land price is fixed and quality is the only consideration. Some briefs offer reasonable compensation for the costs incurred, while others offer nothing and, without a hint of embarrassment, demand a disproportionate financial commitment from five parties. In any case, given the selection processes we have lost, we could make a substantial contribution to an exhibition entitled ‘Never-built Netherlands’. Fortunately, we are still able to submit a winning bid a few times a year.
We see local authorities struggling with the type of brief to issue. Maintaining control over the outcome, and especially over its eventual delivery, remains very difficult. All too often, parties win on the basis of promises they cannot keep. If they cannot fully ‘renegotiate’ those promises during the project development process, the result is often a project of mediocre spatial quality that is difficult to sell, or cannot be sold at all, even in the current housing market. This leads to delays. Another major drawback of tenders is that they often leave some of the market’s creativity untapped. The brief is framed in advance by as many spatial, financial or programme requirements as possible. We see local authorities’ ambitions piling up in these documents. This is understandable to some extent, but because compromises are already being made in advance, there is a risk of missing out on a developer with a brilliant vision that just falls outside the parameters. A consultation round before issuing the brief can largely overcome this drawback.
Fortunately, we also see some wonderful projects taking shape. The quality and professionalism of submissions have improved enormously in recent years, and the briefs themselves are getting better too. It has become a specialism, not something a developer can just take on as an extra. We are learning together, and hopefully, together with local authorities, we will arrive at the ideal brief.
Vraag over dit verhaal? Stel je vraag
Blijf dit volgen
Bij een nieuw verhaal krijg je een e-mail. Geen account nodig.
- OnderwerpGeneral


















