The Pen | Housing is about more than providing homes

The manifestos for the Dutch general election offer a glimpse of what the various political parties want from housing policy. A judicious arrangement of some of the proposals can quickly read like a coalition agreement for the next government.
To paraphrase: ‘Municipalities, housing associations and market players have proved unable to tackle the growing housing shortage and prevent speculation in homes’ (VVD). ‘Housing is once again a government responsibility’ (CDA). ‘We will draw up a national plan to build sustainable, affordable homes’ (SP). ‘Responsibility for housing construction must return to central government’ (PVV) and ‘that is why there will be a Minister for Housing’ (PvdA).
There is little real political disagreement on the numbers, either. The PvdA wants a Minister for Housing to ‘build 100,000 new, affordable homes a year’. The ChristenUnie wants the same number. D66 and GroenLinks want to ‘build more than one million homes before 2030’. The CDA wants to ‘build one million new, sustainable homes within ten years’. The VVD and SP steer clear of figures, but while the SP wants a national plan to build ‘sustainable, affordable homes for everyone’, the VVD is content to say that ‘an affordable home must be within everyone’s reach’.
Here is my prediction for the coalition agreement: ‘The government will strive to increase the housing construction programme to approximately 100,000 homes a year during its term of office.’ The next sentence will be a collection of specific wishes from the individual coalition partners: ‘Priority will be given to affordable homes for purchase and rent for middle-income households. An affordable home must be within everyone’s reach, so we will aim for a minimum of 30% social housing, giving lower-income households, young people, senior citizens, first-time buyers and people with disabilities better access to the housing market.’ The ‘requirements and rules on sustainability will also be tightened’, although with the PVV in government this passage will be less detailed. Housing finance will not be the biggest stumbling block, either. The landlord levy will be converted into a ‘repayment’ to those who paid it and can demonstrate that they deliver on housing-related objectives. In practice, this would amount to a National Solidarity Fund for Housing, run by a self-regulating housing sector.
But housing is about more than measures alone. Ministers do not build homes. At most, they can decide who will build them, or, more accurately, who will be allowed to. And despite their good intentions, most politicians have deeply internalised the idea that they must provide housing for us, the people of the Netherlands. In this top-down approach, roles have been set in stone since the Second World War. In our country, delivery is almost exclusively in the hands of housing associations and property developers. They take this for granted just as much as politicians do. That is a shame, because housing is not just about providing homes for citizens, with tenants as customers and buyers as consumers. I once spoke about this in the corridors of the Dutch House of Representatives with Enneüs Heerma, the former State Secretary for Housing, whom I greatly admired. In a few well-chosen words, he painted the following picture: ‘In our society, people have to choose a school early in life, and that choice shapes their entire working life. They freely choose a partner, decide whether to have children and raise them as they see fit. But someone else decides how they live’. In other words, people in our country are not free to shape their own way of living.
Housing is about more than a roof over your head. It can bring together all kinds of dreams. That is why the conversation should start with what people themselves want from their homes and the way they live. ‘From providing homes to living’[i] literally means that elected representatives give voters the chance to shape their own homes and communities. And yes, the idea appears in an occasional paragraph, but is never translated into performance obligations. So, politicians, there is still much to be done. Give us all the chance to shape our own lives, including where and how we live. Not as an obligation, but as a genuine choice. I do not believe in the impressive figures presented to us. These promises rarely become reality. But if citizens were responsible for a substantial share of housing construction, the Netherlands would already be a more interesting place. The examples show that diversity comes from people themselves, and therefore from what they create. It would be wonderful if, during the next parliamentary term, we had politicians willing to entrust housing to citizens, too. I would say, give it a try and see: housing will be all the richer for it.
Source: [i] Ivan Illich
Vraag over dit verhaal? Stel je vraag
Blijf dit volgen
Bij een nieuw verhaal krijg je een e-mail. Geen account nodig.
- OnderwerpGeneral


















