Projects

Environmentally friendly concrete building materials play an important role in making the construction sector more sustainable

Environmentally friendly concrete building materials play an important role in making the construction sector more sustainable

To make the construction sector genuinely more sustainable, it is important to map the environmental impact of all building materials.

The current MPG calculation method does not account for the temporary storage of CO2 in building materials, making it impossible to map environmental effects clearly. Current MPG calculations therefore cannot show whether a timber building has a high residual value or a concrete building a negative residual value. Because this calculation method does not include temporary CO2 storage, it fails, for example, to adequately show the importance of carbon capture & storage projects for environmentally friendly concrete. Nor does the MPG calculation method reveal the benefits of temporary CO2 storage in bio-based products. The concrete sector is currently working hard to put forward irrefutable facts about how ‘green’ the production process for concrete building materials is. One good example is VBI’s environmentally friendly hollow-core floor. VBI has succeeded in improving the overall environmental profile of its products, further reducing the environmental and CO2 impact of its entire range.

“Building materials will need to perform better if they are to contribute to an 85% reduction in CO2 emissions by 2050, compared with today,” says Mantijn van Leeuwen, director of NIBE, Nederlands Instituut voor Bouwbiologie en Ecologie. NIBE calculates environmental impact using its environmental classifications. These show that concrete performs well, with a modest environmental burden. There is now considerable debate about good and bad building materials. In the Manifest voor een eerlijk speelveld voor een duurzamer Nederland (December 2020), various parties in the construction sector call for a sustainable building standard based on clear calculations. “In this debate, building materials cannot really be labelled good or bad,” says Van Leeuwen. “Per kilogram, concrete is certainly not a material with a high environmental impact compared with glass, steel or aluminium.” When using concrete, the focus should be on the functional unit: what purpose the material serves in a building, how much is needed and what percentage of CO2 emissions it accounts for.

Short-term storage

It is quite complicated to incorporate CO2 storage into the calculation rules. “Our concern is the cumulative CO2 budget up to 2050, for which the Netherlands can emit a total of 950 million tonnes of CO2. The Netherlands currently emits around 180 million tonnes of CO2 each year, so this cannot continue for much longer,” says Van Leeuwen. The path to (almost) zero CO2 emissions in 2050 may therefore be more important than the end point. “Bio-based materials such as timber contribute to CO2 reduction by storing plant-based CO2, provided that the same number of trees are replanted as are harvested. Since the stored CO2 will eventually be released again, this can be viewed as temporary storage.” The current calculation method for determining the environmental impact of building materials used in a building (MPG) does not include the impact of either plant-based or temporary CO2 storage, so we may be missing something. According to Van Leeuwen, product developments in the concrete sector have long been contributing to CO2 savings. “VBI hollow-core floors have already proved their credentials as sustainable concrete building materials. They can last for a hundred years or more, can be designed for disassembly and have an excellent environmental performance,” says Van Leeuwen. “VBI’s green hollow-core floors are even more sustainable, with 30% lower CO2 emissions than standard hollow-core floors. It is rather strange that the construction sector is still not sufficiently aware of these building materials.” According to Van Leeuwen, VBI is a leader in innovations of this kind that demonstrably save CO2.

Strong environmental profile

Peter Musters is a building concepts adviser at VBI. He explains that VBI is constantly working on improvements and innovations for its hollow-core floors. “Our aim is for our building materials to make a substantial contribution to reducing CO2 emissions and, in turn, addressing the climate challenge.” He would prefer each building material not to compete on its own. He believes, however, that construction industry stakeholders should work together to deliver two buildings with net-zero CO2 emissions on the way to 2050. “Our products are used in masonry, concrete and timber structural systems, and this is already happening in practice.” Timber currently has a sustainable, green image. “When VBI introduced its sustainable floor, there was little interest, apart from projects seeking a BREEAM rating. With the right arguments and calculations, we can show that hollow-core floors are designed from the outset to create a functional floor using as little concrete and steel as possible. This immediately gives them a strong environmental profile and makes the masonry-based hollow-core floor an environmentally friendly building material.” Musters explains that VBI has succeeded in improving the overall environmental profile of its products, further reducing the environmental and CO2 impact of its entire range. “The validated environmental shadow price for the complete VBI range was more than 20% lower in 2020 than in 2018.” The results of the latest LCA calculations justify all VBI floors carrying the ‘VBI Kanaalplaatvloeren Groen’ label. The environmental data have now been included in the National Environmental Database (NMD) as Category 1 data, supported by Environmental Product Declarations (EPDs). “To achieve a good environmental score, this product environmental data can be taken directly from the NMD and included in the MPG calculation,” Musters explains.

Lightweight concrete floors

Pim Peters is co-director of IMd Raadgevende Ingenieurs in Rotterdam, one of the parties that signed the construction manifesto for a level playing field. “MPG calculations need to assess not only bio-based materials more fairly, but all building materials, including concrete,” says Peters. IMd specialises in designing sustainable structures. For its designs, it develops comparable structural options and assesses the MPG impact of each. “Hybrid structures are often sustainable because of their material use, adaptability and design for disassembly,” he says. “Concrete remains an important building material, including for floors,” he adds. “To meet sound insulation requirements, mass is needed. Timber hollow-core floors are less suitable in an apartment block, because no one wants to be disturbed by their upstairs neighbours. To solve this, additional structural mass that serves no functional purpose is needed, and this must be included in the MPG calculation.” Lightweight concrete floors, such as hollow-core floors, are more sustainable than a solid concrete floor, which is heavier and has a greater environmental impact. “VBI hollow-core floors have the advantage of being light and containing less material. They are statically determinate elements with spans of up to 14.4 metres. At this size, they have a lower environmental impact than a span of 7.2 metres,” says Peters.

Hybrid structures

Both timber and concrete can be used effectively to balance a building’s net CO2 emissions, for example in hybrid buildings with concrete below ground level and a timber structure above. “The right balance of building materials can be selected according to the function, for example load-bearing timber walls and concrete floors to reduce sound transmission,” says Peters. Concrete remains an essential building material, and ways must be found to use timber as a considered alternative to concrete. The government has a role to play in examining the total CO2 emissions of a building on the way to 2050. For example, it could ask what the demolition costs of a timber or concrete building would be after fifty years. Current MPG calculations cannot show whether a timber building has a high residual value or a concrete building a negative residual value, making it impossible to map environmental effects clearly. NIBE is currently investigating how MPG calculations can be adjusted to provide an accurate indication of short-term CO2 storage. “The cement industry is also working on short-term CO2 storage, for example through carbon capture & storage,” explains Van Leeuwen of NIBE. Cement manufacturer Heidelberg Cement wants to capture CO2 and store it underground for at least fifty years. “This is an excellent and perhaps necessary short-term solution for contributing to CO2 reduction. At present, carbon capture & storage is also excluded from MPG calculations. It should really be included if we want to use MPG calculations to drive short-term CO2 reductions,” says Van Leeuwen.

Vraag over dit verhaal? Stel je vraag

Blijf dit volgen

Bij een nieuw verhaal krijg je een e-mail. Geen account nodig.

Wat je volgt
  • ThemaMinder CO2 in beton en staal
  • OnderwerpProjects
Deel dit artikel

Advertentie

Volgen op Beton & Staalbouw

Volg

Bij een project of bedrijf krijg je een e-mail zodra er een nieuw verhaal over verschijnt, bij een thema of onderwerp één keer per week een overzicht. Geen account en geen wachtwoord: in elke mail staat een link naar wat je volgt.