Monitoring as the foundation of the Binnenhof renovation
Tekst Tjerk van DuinenBeeld Fides Expertise

In this sixth instalment of our series on the renovation of the Binnenhof, we take a closer look at a recurring theme in the construction process: monitoring. Given the immense complexity of this major renovation project, the listed status and age of the buildings, and the interdependence of all the construction activities, monitoring in all its forms is no side issue. It is an integral part of the project as a whole.
The Binnenhof is a group of historic buildings, each with its own project organisation and main contractor. Bianca Derkzen, cross-complex project manager for the renovation at the Central Government Real Estate Agency (RVB), has been coordinating the joint process for five years. “My job is to make sure everything fits together properly, from design through to execution,” she says. “Given the importance of monitoring, this discipline falls under my responsibility. Together with the various structural engineers and construction managers, and Fides Expertise, we work to ensure the entire construction process runs as smoothly as possible.”

Inspections
Monitoring at the Binnenhof is broad in scope and comprehensive. It began at an early stage. “We have been carrying out periodic measurements on the roof structure of the plenary chamber since 2017, long before the renovation began,” says Fred Pannekoek of Fides Expertise. “In 2019, building condition surveys were carried out across the entire complex. Foundation inspections were also conducted. For these inspections, we spent eight months excavating in and around the buildings to establish the depth and type of foundations. This preliminary investigation was incorporated into a baseline monitoring plan and monitoring plans for the various components. All the plans were then developed further in consultation with the relevant structural engineers and project supervisors.” The need for monitoring usually arises from what is going to happen to a building or part of a building. “At the same time, we look at how things are interconnected. If you are creating a basement, for example, that can affect several components.”

Groundwater
Groundwater is also monitored across the entire complex. Pannekoek: “A total of 75 loggers distributed across the site and the surrounding area monitor groundwater levels. Arcadis, which is responsible for the overall dewatering plan, has developed a groundwater management model to show the effects on the existing buildings and surrounding area. We do not measure flow rates directly, but Arcadis calculates the theoretical rate based on differences.”

A survey bolt every five metres
Another form of baseline monitoring uses survey bolts. “Every building here has one every five metres, including in the basements,” says Pannekoek. “Before we started, we agreed with the heritage authorities that we could install survey bolts in the mortar joints everywhere. That means we do not have to consult separately for each building. On natural stone, plates are bonded in place to prevent damage. The survey bolts form the backbone of the monitoring. They are measured periodically using a digital level and a barcode staff. For structures requiring more active monitoring, or where construction activity is higher, monitoring is intensified using fully automated systems.”

Prisms
The Opperhof, the square in front of the Ridderzaal, and the colonnades of the House of Representatives and Senate are among the locations subject to intensive measurement. “There are 360 prisms around the Opperhof alone, which we measure from different angles using six Total Stations,” says Pannekoek. “The prisms have been installed at strategic locations, often in pairs at different heights on the façades, so that a line of sight is always possible, even when there are obstacles such as scaffolding or machinery. The entire area is subject to settlement. That is why we use two stations positioned high up to transfer fixed points from outside to inside via control points. This allows us to monitor with great accuracy, down to tenths of a millimetre. If a control point is temporarily unavailable because of construction activity, it is ‘locked’ and transferred to a new point so that accuracy is maintained.”


Moisture
The Ridderzaal itself, situated in the middle of the work area, is also fitted with survey bolts and prisms all around, and digital crack gauges have been installed at vulnerable locations. “Tilt sensors with laser distance measurement have been installed in the bays of the Ridderzaal, allowing movements between the trusses to be tracked to within a millimetre,” Pannekoek continues. “The idea is that if settlement occurs at the front, it will cause tensile stresses and possibly cracking higher up. These sensors allow us to detect that immediately. Sensors measuring temperature and relative humidity have been installed to monitor the indoor climate in the grafelijke zalen, Algemene Zaken and the Senate. They are connected to an automatic alarm system, so that any deviations can be addressed immediately. Doors may be left open, and the weather has a direct effect. So, for example, if a lot of rain is forecast, the contractor can anticipate rising humidity by adjusting the temperature or using fans.”
Structure-borne vibrations
Construction work causes a lot of vibration. Pannekoek: “That is why vibration meters are installed everywhere, particularly now that floors are being demolished on a large scale. There are currently around eighty active meters, distributed across the buildings and site, and even in the Mauritshuis. The SBR-A guideline provides the basis, but as much of the work is taking place indoors, we mainly measure structure-borne vibrations. If limits are exceeded, the work methods are adjusted. A good example is the concrete base of the fountain in the Opperhof. Demolition with a breaker was stopped after five minutes because the vibration meters showed that the limits had been exceeded. The team then switched to sawing, which stayed within the vibration limits.”

Noise
The vast amount of monitoring data generated across all these different systems calls for a note of caution. Derkzen: “We use the most advanced equipment, but data alone is not enough. You need to know what it means. Machines are constantly moving around, and there are many other sources of vibration that create noise. Or a structure may become damp, triggering an alarm. A subcontractor may interrupt a measurement with scaffolding or a machine. If you do not know what is going on, you keep getting false signals, and this noise can disrupt the monitoring system and delay construction. Organising this effectively throughout the entire construction process is one of the biggest challenges.”

Control
Ultimately, monitoring is about controlling the construction process. Pannekoek: “We are dealing with an extremely complex renovation project involving buildings that we have a duty to protect. To ensure the work proceeds smoothly and safely, without causing damage, decisions must be guided by relevant monitoring signals. This is achieved through clear, prompt and accessible communication with structural engineers, project supervisors and inspectors, including informal daily updates in messaging groups. If there are serious exceedances, we follow the formal route and hold an immediate technical consultation. This keeps the process under control and helps maintain a calm working environment, despite the complexity and the large number of parties involved. Another useful benefit of monitoring is that measurements taken before the project began allow us to demonstrate that movements in buildings or changes in groundwater levels in the surrounding area were not caused by construction activity.”
“Ultimately, it is much more people-focused than an ordinary construction project,” Derkzen concludes. “Good communication is also important for a complex, large-scale project like the Binnenhof. It also determines which parties are suited to taking part.”
Vraag over dit verhaal? Stel je vraag
Wie aan de renovatie van het Binnenhof werkte
- opdrachtgeverRijksvastgoedbedrijfGenoemd in Renovating the former Ministry of the Colonies: a building from the Iron Age
- integraal adviseur voor het Tweede Kamercomplexde Architekten Cie.Genoemd in 1913 architectural ingenuity uncovered during Binnenhof renovation
- TBI-bouwcombinatieJ.P. van Eesteren, Croonwolter&dros en Nico de BontGenoemd in Site offices for 500 people on Plein for Binnenhof renovation
- bouwcombinatieHeijmans BurgyGenoemd in Foundation repair and strengthening at the Binnenhof using grout and gel
- constructieve adviezenArcadisGenoemd in Steel mediates between old and new in the renovation of Binnenhof Building J
- funderingsbedrijf
Keller FunderingstechniekenGenoemd in World market leader at work on Binnenhof renovation - ontwerpBERNS architectuurGenoemd in 1913 architectural ingenuity uncovered during Binnenhof renovation
- adviseurBeersNielsen LichtontwerpersGenoemd in 1913 architectural ingenuity uncovered during Binnenhof renovation
- adviseurBremen BouwadviseursGenoemd in 1913 architectural ingenuity uncovered during Binnenhof renovation
- adviseurSmits van BurgstGenoemd in 1913 architectural ingenuity uncovered during Binnenhof renovation
- adviseurKarres en BrandsGenoemd in 1913 architectural ingenuity uncovered during Binnenhof renovation
- adviseurLevel AcousticsGenoemd in 1913 architectural ingenuity uncovered during Binnenhof renovation
- adviseurHospitality GroepGenoemd in 1913 architectural ingenuity uncovered during Binnenhof renovation
- uitvoeringJ.P. van Eesteren | TBIGenoemd in 1913 architectural ingenuity uncovered during Binnenhof renovation
- installatiesCroonwolter&drosGenoemd in 1913 architectural ingenuity uncovered during Binnenhof renovation
- ontwerpWDJArchitectenGenoemd in Renovating the former Ministry of the Colonies: a building from the Iron Age
- akoestiekLevel Acoustics & VibrationsGenoemd in Renovating the former Ministry of the Colonies: a building from the Iron Age
- uitvoeringNico de BontGenoemd in Renovating the former Ministry of the Colonies: a building from the Iron Age
- circulair staal
EECULAIRGenoemd in Circular observation tower gives residents something back during Binnenhof renovation - jetgrouttechniek
KellerGenoemd in Foundation repair and strengthening at the Binnenhof using grout and gel - bouwcombinatieBouwcombinatie Heijmans BurgyGenoemd in Foundation repair and strengthening at the Binnenhof using grout and gel
- funderingsbedrijfVSFGenoemd in Foundation repair and strengthening at the Binnenhof using grout and gel
- architectVan Hoogevest ArchitectenGenoemd in Steel mediates between old and new in the renovation of Binnenhof Building J
- architectBiermanHenketGenoemd in Binnenhof renovation adds fifth historical layer to Eerste Kamer roof structure
Blijf dit volgen
Bij een nieuw verhaal krijg je een e-mail. Geen account nodig.
- ProjectRenovatie Binnenhof
- ThemaBouwen in de bestaande stad
- OnderwerpGeneral


















